StocksInsight

NI Stock vs the S&P 500: Returns, Risk and Crash History

NiSource Inc., utilities (market value $21.4 billion), an S&P 500 member: how it compared with the S&P 500, how it behaved in every crash since 2008, its risk‑adjusted returns and what analysts said. Returns to Oct 30, 2026; analyst data as of Nov 16, 2026.

Published Updated 4 min readHow we research

What changed since Nov 9

Exent re-checks this page every day. Ratings appear 30 days after they are published; the top‑ranked analysts’ calls are not counted here, they are in Gems.

80% Buy ratings (was 81%)

Key takeaways

  • NI returned +112.0% over the 5 years to Oct 30, 2026 versus +75.9% for the S&P 500: it beat the index.
  • Its 5-year Sharpe ratio was 0.69 against 0.58 for the S&P 500.
  • Its deepest crisis drawdown was −61.9% in the global financial crisis (2007–09) (S&P 500: −56.5%).
  • Five‑year volatility was 20.0% and beta 0.54.
  • 16 analysts rated it in the past year; 80% of their latest calls were Buy.
  • NI beat earnings estimates in 10 of its last 12 reports; the stock moved 1.7% on average, up or down, around each report.

What do the best‑ranked analysts on NI say now? See it in Exent Gems →

Did NI beat the S&P 500?

Over the 5 years to Oct 30, 2026, NiSource Inc. (NI) returned +112.0% including dividends, versus +75.9% for the S&P 500 (SPY). It beat the index by 36.1 percentage points, or +16.2% a year against +12.0%.

PeriodNIS&P 500NI per yearS&P 500 per yearResult
1 year+8.7%+12.0%+8.7%+12.0%Lagged
3 years+93.9%+87.4%+24.7%+23.3%Beat
5 years+112.0%+75.9%+16.2%+12.0%Beat
10 years+163.3%+316.3%+10.2%+15.3%Lagged
  • 1 year
    NI
    +8.7%
    S&P 500
    +12.0%
    NI per year
    +8.7%
    S&P 500 per year
    +12.0%
    Result
    Lagged
  • 3 years
    NI
    +93.9%
    S&P 500
    +87.4%
    NI per year
    +24.7%
    S&P 500 per year
    +23.3%
    Result
    Beat
  • 5 years
    NI
    +112.0%
    S&P 500
    +75.9%
    NI per year
    +16.2%
    S&P 500 per year
    +12.0%
    Result
    Beat
  • 10 years
    NI
    +163.3%
    S&P 500
    +316.3%
    NI per year
    +10.2%
    S&P 500 per year
    +15.3%
    Result
    Lagged

Total return with dividends reinvested, from month-end prices to Oct 30, 2026. Beating the index on raw return is only half the story: the next section adjusts for the risk taken. See also how to beat the S&P 500.

NI is in the S&P 500 (members as of Oct 20, 2026); the list shows every member’s return against the index.

What Wall Street analysts say about NI

In the 12 months to 30 days ago, 16 analysts published 99 ratings on NI. Their latest calls were 80% Buy, 20% Hold and 0% Sell. 5 of them rank 4★ or higher in Exent’s analyst scoring, which is based on each analyst’s past price‑target hit rate and returns.

The consensus 12‑month price target was $49.06 (range $45.00–$52.00), +9.2% from the last price. Remember that the average analyst’s target is hit only about half the time: how accurate are price targets?

Top‑ranked analyst coveringFirmStarsPrice‑target hit rate
??????5.0★44.5%
??????4.9★42.3%
??????4.8★61.1%
??????4.6★38.8%
??????4.5★51.6%

Ratings are shown with a 30‑day delay. Who the top‑ranked analysts on NI are, their live calls and the median target of only the top‑rated analysts are in Exent Gems.

The average analyst’s target is reached about 53.0% of the time; Exent Gems is built on the top 50 of Exent’s ranking,where some reached 90% or more over the last two years. Unlock the top 50 analysts.

NI returns by year vs the S&P 500

NI beat the S&P 500 in 3 of the 9 full calendar years shown.

YearNIS&P 500Difference
2026 (to Oct 30, 2026)+9.6%+11.7%−2.1%
2025+16.8%+17.7%−0.9%
2024+43.5%+24.9%+18.6%
2023+0.5%+26.2%−25.7%
2022+2.7%−18.2%+20.9%
2021+24.8%+28.7%−3.9%
2020−14.9%+18.3%−33.2%
2019+13.1%+31.2%−18.1%
2018+1.9%−4.6%+6.5%
2017+19.2%+21.7%−2.5%

NI risk-adjusted returns: Sharpe, Sortino and volatility

Over 5 years, NI had a Sharpe ratio of 0.69 against 0.58 for the S&P 500, so it earned more return per unit of risk than the index. Its annualized volatility was 19.2% and its beta 0.54: it tended to move about 0.5× as much as the market.

MetricNIS&P 500
Annual return+16.2%+12.0%
Volatility (annualized)19.2%15.5%
Sharpe ratio0.690.58
Sortino ratio1.140.91
Max drawdown (month-end)−19.5%−23.9%
Beta to the S&P 5000.541.00

Sharpe divides return above cash by total volatility; Sortino counts only downside volatility. Both use monthly returns and the 1–3 month T‑bill ETF (BIL) as the risk‑free rate.

How NI behaved in past crashes

NI’s deepest fall in the crises below was −61.9% in the global financial crisis (2007–09), against −56.5% for the S&P 500. The last column turns that into money: what a $100,000 position would have lost from peak to trough.

CrisisNIS&P 500Loss on $100,000
Global financial crisis (2007–09)−61.9%−56.5%−$61,900
2018 trade-war selloff−9.9%−20.2%−$9,880
COVID crash (Feb–Mar 2020)−30.6%−34.1%−$30,580
2022 inflation bear market−25.5%−25.4%−$25,480
2025 tariff selloff−10.0%−19.0%−$9,990
WindowNI max drawdown
Last 1 year−9.2%
Last 3 years−17.8%
Last 5 years−24.8%
Last 10 years−31.7%

Peak‑to‑trough declines from daily prices inside each crisis window. A crash replay does not predict the next crisis; it shows how much room a holding needs. Run the same replay on a whole portfolio with the crash test.

What moves with NI, and what doesn’t

Correlation runs from −1 (moves opposite) to +1 (moves in lockstep). Over the last 60 months of monthly returns, NI’s correlation with the S&P 500 was 0.43, with the Nasdaq‑100 0.22, with long Treasuries (TLT) 0.49 and with gold (GLD) 0.17.

Adding a 5% NI position to an S&P 500 portfolio would have moved its 5‑year volatility from 15.5% to 15.1%.

Least correlated large capsCorrelationMost correlated large capsCorrelation
CRWD−0.25DUK0.82
NOW−0.24SO0.76
NET−0.23WELL0.66
SNOW−0.18MO0.61
CRM−0.17NEE0.61

Holdings that are highly correlated behave like one position in a selloff. See how to find hidden overlap.

Latest NI upgrades, downgrades and price‑target changes

DateRating and targetAnalyst
Oct 20Target cut
Buy
Target $51, was $52
Eli Jossen
J.P. Morgan
Oct 14Target cut
Hold
Target $45, was $47
Ryan Levine
Citi
Oct 13Target cut
Buy
Target $48, was $50
Sophie Karp
KeyBanc
Sep 29New coverage
Hold
Target $43
Ian Rapp
Scotiabank

Named analysts’ rating and price‑target changes on NI in the 5 weeks to Oct 20, 2026, shown 30 days after publication (the free analysts’ calls 3 days after). The top‑ranked analysts’ calls are in Exent Gems. See all of the latest analyst upgrades and downgrades.

Do analysts get NI right?

Of the 153 analyst price targets on NI set from 2019 until a year ago, 79.1% were reached within 12 months (data to Oct 20, 2026), 10.5 points above the 68.6% hit rate of the median stock in Exent’s study of 794 stocks. Targets that were reached took a median of 88 days. The median target sat 9.6% above the share price on the day it was set.

Where analysts said NI would be by now: a year ago, 6 analysts had a price target on NI, and the median of their latest targets was $47.00. On Oct 20, 2026 NI closed at $42.76, 9.0% below it.

79.1%of targets reached within 12 monthsMedian stock: 68.6%
88 daysmedian time to reach a target
−9.0%price now vs the median target set a year ago
AfterCallsMove on the call3 months vs S&P 500
Upgrades of NI8+2.0%+1.2%
Upgrades, all stocks11,514+2.5%+3.4%
Downgrades of NI5−2.2%−4.3%
Downgrades, all stocks10,700−3.0%−1.6%

The move on the call runs from the close before the rating change to the close after it; the last column is the stock’s return minus the S&P 500’s over the next three months. Averages of rating changes on NI through Sep 15, 2026; analysts are not named here. Do analyst upgrades move stocks?

How NI moves after earnings

NI beat the consensus earnings‑per‑share estimate in 10 of its last 12 quarterly reports, through the one on Aug 5, 2026, and the revenue estimate in 7 of 12. From the close before each report to the close after it, the stock moved 1.7% on average, up or down, against 6.8% for the average report across the 1,002 US stocks Exent tracks. It rose after 6 of the 12 reports. In 4 of the 10 beats the stock still fell.

10/12earnings beats
±1.7%average move per report
6/12reports followed by a rise
ReportEPS vs estimateRevenue vs estimateStock move
Aug 5, 2026$0.16 vs $0.16+17.0%−2.6%
May 6, 2026$1.06 vs $1.05−6.3%−2.4%
Feb 11, 2026$0.51 vs $0.50+33.0%+1.0%
Oct 29, 2025$0.19 vs $0.20+6.1%−2.9%
Aug 6, 2025$0.22 vs $0.20+5.7%−1.2%
May 7, 2025$0.98 vs $0.90+1.2%+0.6%
Feb 12, 2025$0.49 vs $0.48−10.6%+3.0%
Oct 30, 2024$0.20 vs $0.16+9.2%+2.9%

Reported earnings per share against the consensus estimate, revenue surprise in percent, and the stock’s price change over the two sessions around the report. How stocks move after earnings

Where NI’s revenue comes from

In fiscal 2023, NI’s largest segment was Gas Distribution Operations, with 67.6% of $5.5 billion revenue (−7.1% on the year before).

SegmentRevenueShareGrowth
Gas Distribution Operations$3.7 billion67.6%−7.1%
Electric Operations$1.8 billion32.4%−2.5%

From NI’s annual filings; segment growth compares fiscal 2023 with the year before. Regions are as each company reports them, so one company’s “Asia Pacific” is not another’s. China counts the regions a company reports as China, Greater China or Hong Kong; a separately reported Taiwan is not counted. Which S&P 500 companies depend most on China?

Members of Congress who traded NI

As of Oct 20, 2026, 5 members of Congress had disclosed 9 trades in NI (4 buys and 5 sales) in STOCK Act disclosures filed with the House and Senate. The latest public trade is dated May 12, 2025.

Trade dateMemberTypeAmount
May 12, 2025Jefferson ShreveSale$50,001–$100,000
Apr 11, 2025Dan NewhouseSale$1,001–$15,000
Sep 3, 2024Ro KhannaBuy$1,001–$15,000
Apr 10, 2024Dan NewhouseBuy$1,001–$15,000
Mar 19, 2021Lois FrankelSale$1,001–$15,000
May 13, 2020Dean PhillipsSale$1,001–$15,000
Apr 2, 2020Dean PhillipsBuy$1,001–$15,000
Dec 6, 2019Lois FrankelBuy$1,001–$15,000
May 28, 2019Dean PhillipsSale$1,001–$15,000

Amounts are the ranges members report, not exact values. The STOCK Act gives members up to 45 days to disclose a trade, so trades appear weeks after they are made. See every member’s disclosed trades

Are NI insiders buying or selling?

In the 12 months to Oct 20, 2026, NI insiders made no open‑market purchases and 7 sales worth $4.9 million, according to SEC Form 4 filings. The last open‑market purchase on record was on Aug 23, 2023.

After the 9 insider purchases of $10,000 or more since 2012, NI beat the S&P 500 by an average of 3.4 percentage points over the next 12 months; 67% of them were followed by a beat. Across all 17,865 insider purchases in Exent’s study, the average was +17.2% and the median +1.0% against the index.

Q3 ’24
Q1 ’25
Q2 ’25
Q3 ’25
Q4 ’25
Q1 ’26
Q2 ’26
Q3 ’26
DateInsiderRoleValue
Aug 23, 2023Yates Lloyd MDirector, officer: Director and President & CEO$1.1 million
May 26, 2021Butler Eric LDirector$5,073
May 25, 2021Butler Eric LDirector$5,065
May 25, 2018Vegas PabloEVP, Gas Business Seg & CCO$362,790
May 9, 2018Butler Eric LDirector$99,300

The table lists the latest open‑market purchases on record, leaving out the last 30 days. The chart counts Form 4 purchases and sales by calendar quarter. Purchases are open‑market buys; sales include planned sales under 10b5‑1 trading plans. Do insider buys beat the market?

How much of NI is sold short?

As of the Sep 30, 2026 settlement date, 3.50% of NI’s float was sold short: 16.7 million shares, or 2.5 days of average trading volume to cover. A year earlier (Oct 15, 2025) it was 2.17%. The median across the 997 US stocks Exent tracks was 4.77%, so NI is less heavily shorted than most.

  • Apr 30, 20262.22%
  • May 29, 20262.28%
  • Jun 30, 20262.69%
  • Jul 31, 20262.79%
  • Aug 31, 20263.07%
  • Sep 30, 20263.50%

From FINRA short‑interest reports, filed twice a month; the bars show the short share of the float at each month‑end. Days to cover divides the shares short by the average daily volume. The most shorted stocks

How many institutions own NI?

At the end of Q2 2026 (Jun 30, 2026), 928 institutions reported holding NI in 13F filings, up 33 from the quarter before and up from 790 a year earlier. Their reported holdings add up to 97.2% of NI’s shares. In the quarter 507 institutions added to their positions and 249 cut them.

92813F holders
108new positions
75positions closed
97.2%of shares held by 13F filers

Investment managers with over $100 million in US equities file 13F reports within 45 days of each quarter end, so this is the latest complete quarter. Holdings can add up to more than 100% when shares are lent and counted twice. Which stocks institutions are buying and selling

Is NI diluting shareholders?

NI’s diluted share count rose 23.5% over the five fiscal years to fiscal 2025 and rose 4.1% in fiscal 2025 alone. Each share now owns a smaller slice of the company. The median change across the 1,005 US stocks Exent tracks was −0.1%.

NI did not buy back shares in fiscal 2025.

+4.1%share count, 1 year
+23.5%share count, 5 years
0.0%stock pay as % of revenue
0.00%buyback yield

Weighted‑average diluted shares from NI’s annual income statements; stock‑based compensation and buybacks from its cash‑flow statement. Stock dilution and stock‑based compensation, explained

NI financial health scores

In Exent’s Oct 20, 2026 snapshot, NI’s Altman Z‑score was 0.75, in the distress zone (where 180 of the 794 non‑financial US stocks Exent tracks sit). Its Piotroski F‑score was 6 out of 9; 62% of scored stocks reach 6 or more.

0.75Altman Z‑score: distress zone
6/9Piotroski F‑score

The Altman Z‑score combines five balance‑sheet and earnings ratios into one bankruptcy‑risk score: below 1.81 is the distress zone, 1.81–2.99 grey, above 2.99 safe. It is not meaningful for banks, insurers and REITs. The Piotroski F‑score counts nine yes/no tests of profitability, leverage and efficiency; 8–9 is strong, 0–2 weak. Both come from the latest annual statements. Which stocks have the highest bankruptcy risk?

What NI talks about on earnings calls

On its latest earnings call (Aug 5, 2026), NI’s executives and analysts mentioned AI 3 times, against 4 on the call before (May 6, 2026); the average across 455 S&P 500 calls that quarter was 12.9. After AI, the most mentioned topic was data centers (18). Tariffs and recession did not come up.

MentionsAug ’26May ’26Feb ’26Oct ’25
AI3416
AI agents0000
Data centers18151318
Tariffs0000
China0000
Recession0000
  • AI
    Aug ’26
    3
    May ’26
    4
    Feb ’26
    1
    Oct ’25
    6
  • AI agents
    Aug ’26
    0
    May ’26
    0
    Feb ’26
    0
    Oct ’25
    0
  • Data centers
    Aug ’26
    18
    May ’26
    15
    Feb ’26
    13
    Oct ’25
    18
  • Tariffs
    Aug ’26
    0
    May ’26
    0
    Feb ’26
    0
    Oct ’25
    0
  • China
    Aug ’26
    0
    May ’26
    0
    Feb ’26
    0
    Oct ’25
    0
  • Recession
    Aug ’26
    0
    May ’26
    0
    Feb ’26
    0
    Oct ’25
    0

Word counts in the full transcript of each call, prepared remarks and Q&A, newest first. “AI” also counts generative AI and large language models; “AI agents” counts agentic AI. Which companies talk most about AI?

Which ETFs hold NI?

As of Oct 20, 2026, 52 of the 304 ETFs Exent tracks held NI. Its largest weight is in XLU (State Street Utilities Select Sector SPDR ETF), at 1.55% of the fund.

ETFFundWeight of NI
XLUState Street Utilities Select Sector SPDR ETF1.55%
FUTYFidelity MSCI Utilities Index ETF1.39%
VPUVanguard Utilities Index Fund ETF Shares1.35%
JXIiShares Global Utilities ETF0.94%
DVYiShares Select Dividend ETF0.79%
ESGUiShares ESG Aware MSCI USA ETF0.44%
VBRVanguard Small-Cap Value Index Fund ETF Shares0.43%
SCHMSchwab U.S. Mid-Cap ETF0.42%

Owning several of these funds stacks the same position. How much do VOO, QQQ and VTI overlap?

The right benchmark for NI

Exent matches every holding to the index with the most similar risk. For NI that is SPY (the S&P 500). Comparing a holding with an index that carries very different risk makes good results look bad and risky ones look clever. Read why the S&P 500 is the wrong benchmark for most portfolios.

Other utilities stocks

TickerName5‑year returnVolatility (5y)
NEENextEra Energy, Inc.+12.2%26.9%
SOThe Southern Company+80.5%18.6%
DUKDuke Energy Corporation+51.4%18.1%
EVRGEvergy, Inc.+64.5%18.9%
CMSCMS Energy Corporation+35.6%19.1%
NRGNRG Energy, Inc.+172.4%39.8%
EIXEdison International+18.9%29.1%
LNTAlliant Energy Corporation+49.1%19.7%

Data and methodology

Returns are total returns from month‑end adjusted closing prices (dividends reinvested) through Oct 30, 2026. Crisis drawdowns and trailing maximum drawdowns use daily prices. Analyst coverage counts ratings published in the last 12 months, shown with a 30‑day delay. Full method: Exent methodology.

Company data as of Oct 20, 2026. The move around an earnings report runs from the close before it to the close after it; a price target counts as hit when the stock closed at or beyond it within 12 months (Exent analyst data). Revenue by region and segment, share counts and executive pay come from company filings; insider trades from SEC Form 4, short interest from FINRA, institutional ownership from 13F filings, Congress trades from STOCK Act disclosures filed with the House and Senate, federal contracts from USAspending.gov. Filings from the last 30 days are shown as counts only.

Past performance does not guarantee future results. Historical figures are calculated by Exent from market data and are for education only; they are not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security.

Check NI with Exent Gems

Wall Street’s average NI price target is 9.2% above the latest share price. See what the best‑ranked analysts on NI say now in Exent Gems.

  1. Exent ranks Wall Street analysts by their past price‑target hit rate and returns, and keeps the best‑ranked few.
  2. Gems shows who the top‑ranked analysts covering NI are, their live calls and the median target of only the top‑rated analysts.
  3. Gems flags the stocks where several top‑ranked analysts agree: a starting point for your own research, not a promise.

Exent is our product. Educational content, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

No. NI returned +163.3% (+10.2% a year) over the 10 years to Oct 30, 2026, versus +316.3% (+15.3% a year) for the S&P 500, including dividends.

Yes. As of Oct 20, 2026, NI (NiSource Inc.) is one of the 503 stocks in the S&P 500.

NI fell −61.9% from peak to trough during the global financial crisis (2007–09), versus −56.5% for the S&P 500.

NI fell −30.6% from peak to trough during the covid crash (feb–mar 2020), versus −34.1% for the S&P 500.

NI fell −25.5% from peak to trough during the 2022 inflation bear market, versus −25.4% for the S&P 500.

Over the 5 years to Oct 30, 2026, NI’s Sharpe ratio was 0.69 and its Sortino ratio 1.14, versus 0.58 and 0.91 for the S&P 500.

NI’s 5‑year annualized volatility was 20.0%, higher than the S&P 500’s 17.0%, with a beta of 0.54.

Among large US stocks, the lowest correlations with NI over the last 60 months were CRWD (−0.25), NOW (−0.24), NET (−0.23). Its correlation with long Treasuries (TLT) was 0.49 and with gold (GLD) 0.17.

NI beat the consensus earnings-per-share estimate in 10 of its last 12 quarterly reports through Aug 5, 2026, and the revenue estimate in 7 of 12. The stock moved 1.7% on average, up or down, from the close before each report to the close after it.

Yes. As of Oct 20, 2026, 5 members of Congress had disclosed 9 trades in NI (4 buys and 5 sales) in STOCK Act disclosures filed with the House and Senate.

As of the Sep 30, 2026 settlement date, 3.50% of NI’s float was sold short (16.7 million shares, 2.5 days to cover), according to FINRA short-interest reports. A year earlier it was 2.17%.

Yes. NI’s diluted share count rose 23.5% over the five fiscal years to fiscal 2025 and rose 4.1% in the latest year. Stock-based compensation was 0.0% of revenue.

What do the best‑ranked analysts say on NI now?

Exent ranks Wall Street analysts by their track record. Gems shows who the top‑ranked analysts on NI are, their latest calls and the stocks where several of them agree.

See this week’s GemsLimited offer$1.95 for full access· full access

Educational content, not investment advice. Examples are illustrative; past performance does not guarantee future results.

DISCLAIMER: Exent AI is an informational research platform and does not provide investment advice, financial advice, or act as an investment adviser, broker-dealer, or fiduciary. All content, analytics, and model outputs are provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any financial instrument. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Exent AI does not execute trades, hold customer funds, or provide brokerage services. Past performance and hypothetical results are not indicative of future results. Third-party data and AI-generated outputs may be incomplete or inaccurate.