ResourcesGuide

How Did Common Hedges Do in 2008, 2020 and 2022?

Exent tested 12 popular diversifiers against the S&P 500: bonds, gold, T‑bills, commodities and “defensive” stock funds. Here is how each behaved in 2008, the COVID crash and 2022, and in every bad month since 2016.

Published Updated 8 min readHow we research

Key takeaways

  • Inconsistently. Only T‑bills held steady in all three. Long Treasuries rose 13.4% in the COVID crash but lost 31.2% in 2022; commodities gained 19.3% in 2022 but lost 22.9% in early 2020 (Exent’s data, Sep 30, 2026).
  • In the 16 months since mid‑2016 when the S&P 500 fell more than 4%, it averaged −6.7%; T‑bills +0.2%, gold −0.4%, 7–10 year Treasuries −0.9%.
  • “Defensive” stock funds softened losses but did not diversify: their correlations with the S&P 500 were 0.82 to 0.95.
  • Correlations rose when it mattered: 11 of 12 funds were more correlated with stocks across all months than in calm months.

What is your own portfolio exposed to? Check it with Exent →

How did common hedges perform in 2008, 2020 and 2022?

Each hedge worked in some crises and failed in others, because each crisis had a different cause: a credit collapse in 2008, a sudden shock in 2020, and an inflation and rate shock in 2022.

Fund2008 crisis: deepest fallCOVID: Feb–Mar 20202022 calendar year
S&P 500 (SPY)−56.5%−19.4%−18.2%
T-bills (BIL)−1.1%+0.3%+1.4%
20+ year Treasuries (TLT)−16.7%+13.4%−31.2%
7–10 year Treasuries (IEF)−7.1%+6.8%−15.2%
US aggregate bonds (AGG)−14.6%+1.0%−13.0%
Gold (GLD)−29.4%−0.9%−0.8%
Commodities (DBC)−60.9%−22.9%+19.3%
High-dividend stocks (SCHD)n/a−20.1%−3.2%
Minimum volatility (USMV)n/a−19.1%−9.4%
Dividend growth (VIG)−48.2%−17.1%−9.8%
Equal-weight S&P 500 (RSP)−60.0%−25.3%−11.6%
Small caps (IWM)−59.2%−28.4%−20.5%
Nasdaq-100 (QQQ)−53.6%−12.9%−32.6%

Exent’s data as of Sep 30, 2026, total returns. The 2008 column is the deepest peak‑to‑trough fall inside the October 2007 to March 2009 window, a harsher measure than a period return; the 2020 column is month‑end January to month‑end March 2020. Each fund has its own data page, for example TLT, GLD and DBC.

Which assets held up when stocks fell more than 4% in a month?

Three crises are a small sample, so Exent also looked at every bad month. From mid‑2016 to Sep 30, 2026, the S&P 500 fell more than 4% in 16 months and averaged −6.7% in them.

FundAverage in the 16 bad monthsCorrelation with S&P 500, all monthsCorrelation, calm months only
T-bills (BIL)+0.2%0.000.05
Gold (GLD)−0.4%0.140.10
7–10 year Treasuries (IEF)−0.9%0.180.16
20+ year Treasuries (TLT)−1.9%0.190.18
Commodities (DBC)−1.2%0.340.28
US aggregate bonds (AGG)−1.2%0.400.32
High-dividend stocks (SCHD)−5.5%0.820.71
Small caps (IWM)−8.4%0.860.76
Minimum volatility (USMV)−4.9%0.870.77
Nasdaq-100 (QQQ)−7.6%0.910.85
Equal-weight S&P 500 (RSP)−7.0%0.930.88
Dividend growth (VIG)−5.8%0.950.90

Monthly total returns, same data. A correlation near 0 means a fund’s moves had little to do with the stock market’s; near 1 means they moved together (see correlation coefficient). None of the 12 funds had a negative correlation with stocks over the period, which is why truly negatively correlated assets are rare.

Do correlations rise in a crash?

In this data, yes. For 11 of the 12 funds, the correlation with the S&P 500 was higher across all months than in calm months alone, which means the bad months pulled them closer to stocks. The only exception was T‑bills. For the stock funds the jump was about 0.05 to 0.11; for aggregate bonds it was 0.32 to 0.40.

That is the practical problem with diversification: a mix that looks well spread in normal times can behave like one position in a selloff. Why it happens, and how to measure it, is covered in correlations in crashes.

Do defensive stock funds diversify a portfolio?

They reduce the size of losses a little, but they do not diversify. Minimum‑volatility, dividend and equal‑weight funds are still stock funds, with correlations of 0.82 to 0.95 with the S&P 500. In the 16 bad months they averaged −4.9% to −7.0%, against −6.7% for the index.

Their protection also depended on the crisis. In the COVID crash, the minimum‑volatility fund fell 19.1%, almost exactly the S&P 500’s 19.4%, and equal weight fell more (25.3%). In 2022, high dividend (−3.2%) and minimum volatility (−9.4%) did much better than the index. Growth‑heavy QQQ did the reverse: better in 2020 (−12.9%), much worse in 2022 (−32.6%).

Did multi‑asset mixes protect better?

Combining assets that fail in different crises smoothed results, at a cost in long‑run return. Hypothetical backtests on the same data, mid‑2016 to Sep 30, 2026:

BacktestHoldingsFeb–Mar 20202022Annual return
S&P 500SPY−19.4%−18.2%15.2%
60/40SPY 60 / AGG 40−11.5%−15.8%9.5%
All-weather-styleSPY 30 / TLT 40 / IEF 15 / GLD 7.5 / DBC 7.5−1.8%−19.3%5.1%
Risk parity (from Jul 2017)SPY / TLT / GLD by inverse volatility−3.8%−18.2%8.7%
Trend filterSPY, to T-bills below its 10-month average−7.7%−20.1%9.4%
  • S&P 500
    Holdings
    SPY
    Feb–Mar 2020
    −19.4%
    2022
    −18.2%
    Annual return
    15.2%
  • 60/40
    Holdings
    SPY 60 / AGG 40
    Feb–Mar 2020
    −11.5%
    2022
    −15.8%
    Annual return
    9.5%
  • All-weather-style
    Holdings
    SPY 30 / TLT 40 / IEF 15 / GLD 7.5 / DBC 7.5
    Feb–Mar 2020
    −1.8%
    2022
    −19.3%
    Annual return
    5.1%
  • Risk parity (from Jul 2017)
    Holdings
    SPY / TLT / GLD by inverse volatility
    Feb–Mar 2020
    −3.8%
    2022
    −18.2%
    Annual return
    8.7%
  • Trend filter
    Holdings
    SPY, to T-bills below its 10-month average
    Feb–Mar 2020
    −7.7%
    2022
    −20.1%
    Annual return
    9.4%

Hypothetical backtests, past results, not a recommendation. The bond‑heavy mixes nearly sidestepped 2020 and then lost as much as stocks in 2022, because their main hedge failed that year. Details on 60/40, all‑weather‑style and risk parity.

How to use this when checking your own portfolio

  • Name the crash you are hedging: Treasuries helped in a growth scare, commodities in an inflation shock, T‑bills in both but with no upside.
  • Do not count defensive stock funds as diversifiers; count them as lower‑risk stocks.
  • Look at correlation in bad months, not just on average.
  • Expect a cost: every steadier asset here, gold included, earned less than the S&P 500 over the decade.
  • Test your actual mix, not the labels: check which holdings move together and how the whole portfolio did in 2008, 2020, 2022 and 2025.

For the full menu of approaches, from options to cash, start at the guide to hedging a portfolio, and see what each costs in the cost of hedging.

How to test your diversifiers with Exent

  1. Upload a screenshot of your holdings (or a CSV, Excel, PDF or Google Sheet); no brokerage login.
  2. Exent groups holdings that move together into correlation clusters, so defensive stock funds that behave like stocks show up in the stock cluster.
  3. It replays the portfolio through 2008, 2018, 2020, 2022 and 2025; the what‑if simulator shows the effect of adding T‑bills, Treasuries or gold before you trade.

Exent is our product. Educational content, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

Of the funds Exent tested, T-bills held up best, with a deepest fall of 1.1% inside the 2007–09 window. Intermediate Treasuries fell as much as 7.1% and long Treasuries 16.7%, against 56.5% for the S&P 500.

Commodities gained 19.3% and T-bills 1.4%, and gold returned −0.8%. Bonds fell with stocks: long Treasuries lost 31.2% and aggregate bonds 13.0%.

Long Treasuries gained 13.4% in February and March 2020 while the S&P 500 lost 19.4%. Commodities lost 22.9% over the same months.

Not a true hedge. Dividend ETFs had correlations of 0.82 and 0.95 with the S&P 500 and lost money in the same bad months, though usually a little less.

In Exent’s data since mid-2016, T-bills had a correlation of 0.00 with the S&P 500 and gold 0.14. Both are close to zero rather than negative.

See what your portfolio is really made of.

Upload a screenshot of your holdings and get concentration, overlap, crash exposure and a risk-matched benchmark in about a minute.

Check my portfolioLimited offer$1.95 for unlimited checks· unlimited checks

Educational content, not investment advice. Examples are illustrative; past performance does not guarantee future results.

DISCLAIMER: Exent AI is an informational research platform and does not provide investment advice, financial advice, or act as an investment adviser, broker-dealer, or fiduciary. All content, analytics, and model outputs are provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any financial instrument. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Exent AI does not execute trades, hold customer funds, or provide brokerage services. Past performance and hypothetical results are not indicative of future results. Third-party data and AI-generated outputs may be incomplete or inaccurate.