ResourcesGuide

How to Build a Lower‑Risk Portfolio: 9 Mixes Compared

Nine portfolios, from half in T‑bills to high‑beta stocks, compared on return, volatility and worst fall over ten years, plus buffer and income funds since 2020 and a timed alternative. With a defensive‑asset check that updates every trading day.

Published Updated 7 min readHow we research

Key takeaways

  • The most reliable way to lower risk was to hold less in stocks. A 60/40 stock‑bond mix returned 9.6% a year with a −21.5% worst fall from mid‑2016 to Sep 2026, against 15.2% and −33.7% for the S&P 500 (Exent’s data).
  • T‑bills made a better safe half than bonds in this decade: 60% stocks with 40% T‑bills returned 10.1% a year and lost 15.0% in the 2022 bear market, against 20.5% for the mix with bonds.
  • Low‑volatility stock funds did not protect in the COVID crash: USMV fell 33.1% and SPLV 36.3%, about as much as the index, though both lost less in 2022.
  • Buffer and income funds had a −13.7% worst fall from Sep 2020 to Sep 2026, against −24.5% for the S&P 500, while returning 9.0% to 10.5% a year.
  • A timed approach reached a similar place by a different route: a hypothetical 200‑day rule on the S&P 500 returned 10.3% a year with a −19.2% worst fall, but switched 58 times.

What is your own portfolio exposed to? Check it with Exent →

How do I reduce risk in my portfolio?

Start with the largest fall you could sit through without selling, then hold a mix whose worst past fall fits inside it. Three moves do most of the work: hold less in stocks, choose what the rest sits in, and cut concentrated or high‑beta holdings. Before the first move, remove risk you are not paid for, such as duplicate funds and oversized single stocks (see how to reduce risk without lowering returns). To check where you stand, see how to know if your portfolio is too risky.

The table compares nine portfolios in Exent’s data over Jul 2016 – Sep 2026, rebalanced monthly, total return, measured on daily closes, so worst falls are slightly deeper than month‑end figures elsewhere in this library. “Bonds” are US aggregate bonds (AGG). Crash protection more broadly is in the portfolio protection guide.

PortfolioReturn a yearVolatilityWorst fall2022 bearCOVID 2020
100% S&P 50015.2%17.8%−33.7%−24.5%−33.7%
80% S&P 500 / 20% bonds12.4%14.3%−27.7%−22.4%−27.7%
60% S&P 500 / 40% bonds9.6%11.0%−21.5%−20.5%−21.5%
60% S&P 500 / 40% T‑bills10.1%10.5%−20.8%−15.0%−20.8%
50% S&P 500 / 50% T‑bills8.8%8.7%−17.4%−12.5%−17.4%
Min‑volatility US stocks (USMV)9.4%14.4%−33.1%−17.8%−33.1%
Low‑volatility S&P 500 (SPLV)7.2%15.3%−36.3%−17.3%−36.3%
100% Nasdaq‑100 (QQQ)21.5%22.3%−35.1%−34.8%−28.6%
High‑beta S&P 500 (SPHB)18.7%28.5%−46.8%−30.1%−46.6%
  • 100% S&P 500
    Return a year
    15.2%
    Volatility
    17.8%
    Worst fall
    −33.7%
    2022 bear
    −24.5%
    COVID 2020
    −33.7%
  • 80% S&P 500 / 20% bonds
    Return a year
    12.4%
    Volatility
    14.3%
    Worst fall
    −27.7%
    2022 bear
    −22.4%
    COVID 2020
    −27.7%
  • 60% S&P 500 / 40% bonds
    Return a year
    9.6%
    Volatility
    11.0%
    Worst fall
    −21.5%
    2022 bear
    −20.5%
    COVID 2020
    −21.5%
  • 60% S&P 500 / 40% T‑bills
    Return a year
    10.1%
    Volatility
    10.5%
    Worst fall
    −20.8%
    2022 bear
    −15.0%
    COVID 2020
    −20.8%
  • 50% S&P 500 / 50% T‑bills
    Return a year
    8.8%
    Volatility
    8.7%
    Worst fall
    −17.4%
    2022 bear
    −12.5%
    COVID 2020
    −17.4%
  • Min‑volatility US stocks (USMV)
    Return a year
    9.4%
    Volatility
    14.4%
    Worst fall
    −33.1%
    2022 bear
    −17.8%
    COVID 2020
    −33.1%
  • Low‑volatility S&P 500 (SPLV)
    Return a year
    7.2%
    Volatility
    15.3%
    Worst fall
    −36.3%
    2022 bear
    −17.3%
    COVID 2020
    −36.3%
  • 100% Nasdaq‑100 (QQQ)
    Return a year
    21.5%
    Volatility
    22.3%
    Worst fall
    −35.1%
    2022 bear
    −34.8%
    COVID 2020
    −28.6%
  • High‑beta S&P 500 (SPHB)
    Return a year
    18.7%
    Volatility
    28.5%
    Worst fall
    −46.8%
    2022 bear
    −30.1%
    COVID 2020
    −46.6%

Market risk check, updated every trading day

Data through the close of Nov 18, 2026. The S&P 500 fell 3.9% over the last five trading days, and the Nasdaq‑100 fell 4.5%. The S&P 500 is 6.3% below its record close of Oct 6: a pullback (5–10% off the record). It is 0.3% below its 200‑day average (+3.9% a week earlier). Its 20‑day volatility is 22.9% a year, rougher than 88% of trading days since 2016.

The S&P 500 vs its 200‑day average

Daily closes over the last year, through Nov 18, 2026. Green: the index above its average; red: below it.

−6.3%from its record closeRecord: Oct 6, 2026
−0.3%vs its 200‑day averageA week earlier: +3.9%
22.9%20‑day volatility (a year)Median since 2016: 12.2%
−3.9%last five trading daysNasdaq‑100: −4.5%

Where money goes when investors step aside

Returns through Nov 18, 2026, dividends and interest included.

AssetLast 5 days1 monthYear to date1 year
T‑bills, 1–3 months (BIL)+0.1%+0.3%+3.2%+3.7%
Treasuries, 1–3 years (SHY)0.0%+0.4%+1.2%+1.8%
Treasuries, 7–10 years (IEF)−0.3%+0.8%−2.5%−2.3%
Treasuries, 20+ years (TLT)−0.9%+0.5%−4.4%−5.7%
US bond market (AGG)−0.3%+0.6%−1.1%−0.6%
Gold (GLD)−6.6%−9.7%−13.9%−8.2%
Min‑volatility stocks (USMV)−2.9%−1.0%+8.7%+9.6%
−1× S&P 500 (SH)+4.1%+5.5%−3.4%−5.3%

Exent macro regime score, today

Last updated Nov 18, 2026. Members only.

Exent regime pillarToday
Liquidity
Credit stress
Economic cycle
Sentiment
Regime: Risk ON · Neutral · Risk OFF

Price trend and volatility show what the market has already done. Exent’s macro regime score reads the backdrop behind it (liquidity, credit stress, the economic cycle and sentiment) and classifies it as Risk ON, Neutral or Risk OFF. Market intel members see today’s reading and get an alert when it changes.

Exent market data, daily closes; returns include dividends and interest. The S&P 500, Nasdaq‑100 and Russell 2000 are shown through the SPY, QQQ and IWM funds. Refreshed every trading day. It describes conditions; it is not a forecast or a recommendation. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Which lower‑risk mix gave the best trade‑off?

In this decade, mixes with T‑bills gave the best trade‑off. The 60% stock / 40% T‑bill mix returned more than the 60/40 mix with bonds (10.1% vs 9.6% a year), swung less (10.5% vs 11.0% volatility) and lost less in the 2022 bear market (15.0% vs 20.5%). The 50/50 T‑bill mix had the smallest worst fall of all nine, −17.4%, for 8.8% a year.

That edge came from one bad stretch for bonds, when inflation pushed rates up in 2022. In a crash where rates fall, longer bonds can cushion more than bills; the record by crash is in cash, T‑bills or bonds when you step aside. Adding more asset classes is not automatically better either. Morningstar figures reported by The Daily Upside on Yahoo Finance in April 2026 show a broad 11‑asset portfolio beating a 60/40 mix in 2025 (about 18% vs 13%), but trailing it over the 20 years through 2025 (7.13% vs 8.22% a year).

The stock share is the main dial. Holding less cut return and worst fall roughly in proportion: the 60/40 mix kept about 63% of the index’s yearly return and took about 64% of its worst fall. How the share usually changes with age is in asset allocation by age.

Do low‑volatility funds lower risk?

They lowered everyday swings, not the worst crash. Min‑volatility US stocks (USMV) had 14.4% volatility against 17.8% for the S&P 500, but fell 33.1% in the COVID crash, almost the index’s 33.7%; the low‑volatility S&P 500 fund (SPLV) fell 36.3%, more than the index. In slower, sector‑driven selloffs they helped: in 2022 they lost 17.8% and 17.3% against 24.5%.

The lesson is that low volatility and a small worst fall are different things. In a panic, most stocks fall together, and only assets outside the stock market, such as T‑bills, held their value. At the other end, high‑beta stocks (SPHB) returned 18.7% a year with a −46.8% worst fall, and the Nasdaq‑100 (QQQ) 21.5% with −35.1%.

Do buffer and income funds make a portfolio less volatile?

They did since 2020, at a cost in return. These funds use options to trade upside for smaller falls. From September 2020, when all of them have data:

PortfolioReturn a yearVolatilityWorst fall2022 bear2025 tariffs
100% S&P 50015.2%16.8%−24.5%−24.5%−18.8%
Buffer ETF ladder (BUFR)10.5%10.1%−13.7%−13.7%−12.8%
Covered‑call income (JEPI)9.0%10.8%−13.7%−13.7%−13.3%
Min‑volatility US stocks (USMV)8.5%12.3%−17.9%−17.8%−9.4%
60% S&P 500 / 40% bonds8.7%10.7%−20.7%−20.5%−11.2%
  • 100% S&P 500
    Return a year
    15.2%
    Volatility
    16.8%
    Worst fall
    −24.5%
    2022 bear
    −24.5%
    2025 tariffs
    −18.8%
  • Buffer ETF ladder (BUFR)
    Return a year
    10.5%
    Volatility
    10.1%
    Worst fall
    −13.7%
    2022 bear
    −13.7%
    2025 tariffs
    −12.8%
  • Covered‑call income (JEPI)
    Return a year
    9.0%
    Volatility
    10.8%
    Worst fall
    −13.7%
    2022 bear
    −13.7%
    2025 tariffs
    −13.3%
  • Min‑volatility US stocks (USMV)
    Return a year
    8.5%
    Volatility
    12.3%
    Worst fall
    −17.9%
    2022 bear
    −17.8%
    2025 tariffs
    −9.4%
  • 60% S&P 500 / 40% bonds
    Return a year
    8.7%
    Volatility
    10.7%
    Worst fall
    −20.7%
    2022 bear
    −20.5%
    2025 tariffs
    −11.2%

The buffer ladder (BUFR) and the covered‑call fund (JEPI) both had a −13.7% worst fall and returned 10.5% and 9.0% a year, against 15.2% for the index. The window is six years with one bear market, and both cap or sell away part of the upside in strong years. Caps, fees and timing are covered in are buffer ETFs worth it.

Is there a lower‑risk option that changes with the market?

Yes: instead of holding a fixed safe share every year, some investors change exposure when conditions turn. The simplest version is a price rule. In this hypothetical backtest (Jan 2017 – Sep 2026, before trading costs and taxes), the S&P 500 was held while it closed above its 200‑day average and swapped for T‑bills while it was below:

FundHold: a yearHold: worst fall200‑day rule: a yearRule: worst fallTime invested
S&P 500 (SPY)15.1%−33.7%10.3%−19.2%82%
FundS&P 500 (SPY)
Hold: a year15.1%
Hold: worst fall−33.7%
200‑day rule: a year10.3%
Rule: worst fall−19.2%
Time invested82%

The rule landed close to the 60/40 T‑bill mix: 10.3% a year and a −19.2% worst fall over its window, against 10.1% and −20.8% for the mix from mid‑2016. It got there by being fully invested 82% of the time and out the rest. The price was 58 switches, each a taxable sale in a taxable account, and missed rebounds. Stepping between exposure levels is explained in risk‑on vs risk‑off portfolios; timing based on economic conditions rather than price is what a macro regime score, such as the one on Market intel, is for.

How to choose your lower‑risk mix

  • Write the worst fall in dollars. Illustrative: on $1,000,000, the 60/40 mix’s −21.5% is $215,000; the S&P 500’s −33.7% is $337,000.
  • Remove duplicate funds and trim oversized single stocks before cutting overall stock exposure.
  • Match the safe part to the risk: T‑bills held up in every selloff here; longer bonds helped only when rates fell.
  • Do not count on low‑volatility stock funds to cushion a panic; count on assets outside stocks.
  • Rebalance on a schedule, and check the mix against your own time horizon and cash needs.

How to test a lower‑risk mix on your own holdings with Exent

  1. Upload a screenshot of your holdings, or a CSV, Excel, PDF or Google Sheet; no brokerage login.
  2. Exent replays your portfolio through 2008, 2018, 2020, 2022 and 2025 and shows the loss in dollars.
  3. An efficient frontier chart shows where your mix sits on return versus risk, and the what‑if simulator lets you change tickers and weights to compare a lower‑risk mix before you trade.

Featured on Business Insider · Yahoo Finance · Benzinga

Exent is our product. Educational content, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

One whose worst historical fall is smaller than the stock market’s, usually because part of it sits in T-bills or bonds. In Exent’s data a 60/40 stock-bond mix fell 21.5% at worst from mid-2016 to September 2026, against 33.7% for the S&P 500.

In this period, a 60% stock and 40% T-bill mix returned 10.1% a year with 10.5% volatility, against 15.2% and 17.8% for the S&P 500. Removing duplicate funds and oversized single stocks first can cut risk without giving up as much return.

They cut everyday swings but not every crash. USMV fell 33.1% in the 2020 COVID crash, nearly as much as the S&P 500, though it lost less in 2022 and 2025.

It had smaller falls than stocks in each selloff since 2018, but in 2022 bonds fell too and the mix lost 20.5% during the bear market. The mix with T-bills instead of bonds lost 15.0%.

From mid-2016 to September 2026, T-bills did: the 60/40 mix with T-bills had lower volatility and a smaller 2022 loss than the one with bonds. Bonds can do better in a crash that comes with falling interest rates.

Roughly in proportion to the risk removed. A 60/40 mix kept about 63% of the S&P 500’s yearly return (9.6% vs 15.2%) and took about 64% of its worst fall (21.5% vs 33.7%).

See what your portfolio is really made of.

Upload a screenshot of your holdings and get concentration, overlap, crash exposure and a risk-matched benchmark in about a minute.

Check my portfolioLimited offer$1.95 for unlimited checks· unlimited checks

Educational content, not investment advice. Examples are illustrative; past performance does not guarantee future results.

DISCLAIMER: Exent AI is an informational research platform and does not provide investment advice, financial advice, or act as an investment adviser, broker-dealer, or fiduciary. All content, analytics, and model outputs are provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any financial instrument. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Exent AI does not execute trades, hold customer funds, or provide brokerage services. Past performance and hypothetical results are not indicative of future results. Third-party data and AI-generated outputs may be incomplete or inaccurate.