ResourcesGuide

Should I Invest My House Down Payment? It Depends on When You Buy

Money for a home you plan to buy soon has a date attached, and the market does not know it. Here is how the worst historical results change with 1, 3 and 5 years to go, what that meant for a $60,000 goal, and where people usually keep each slice.

Published Updated 9 min readHow we research

Key takeaways

  • If you plan to buy within about 2 years, history argues for keeping the down payment out of stocks: the S&P 500 lost as much as 43.8% in one calendar year (1931) and 36.6% in 2008 (Exent calculation on NYU Stern data, 1928–2025).
  • With 2 to 5 years to go, a common choice is short Treasuries, CDs or similar; longer bonds can fall too, as the 10-year Treasury did in 2022 (−17.8%).
  • With 5 or more years, some stock exposure is common, but even 60% stocks / 40% 10-year Treasuries lost 24.1% over 1928–32. Since 1950 its worst 5-year result was +8.9%.
  • Worked example: $53,000 aiming for $60,000 in 3 years. At the 3-year Treasury yield of 4.72% (Oct 22, 2026), compounded annually, it comes to about $60,900 (an illustration; the actual result depends on purchase terms and coupon reinvestment); 100% stocks fell short in 20 of 96 past 3-year windows, and the worst left $20,362.
  • A mix lowers how badly you can miss, not how often: 60/40 missed the same $60,000 target in 21 of 96 windows, but its worst outcome was $32,309 instead of $20,362.

Market risk reading, cross‑asset context and an events calendar: see Exent Market intel →

Should I invest my down payment in stocks?

If you need the money within about 2 years, history says the risk is hard to justify; with 2 to 5 years it depends on how flexible your purchase date is; with 5 or more years, some stocks are common. The reason is simple: a stock-heavy mix can lose a third of its value in a year, and a home purchase is a fixed date you cannot move without cost.

Scope. US savers putting money aside for a first or next home, in a bank, a taxable brokerage account or Treasuries, under rules as of October 26, 2026. Not covered: choosing a mortgage, local housing markets, and how big your emergency fund should be (see how much cash to keep; that money is separate from the down payment and usually stays out of the market for the same reason). Everything here is education with hypothetical numbers, not a recommendation for your situation.

Time until you buyWhat people commonly useWhy
Under 2 yearsInsured savings, CDs, Treasury bills or T-bill fundsStocks lost money in 26 of 98 calendar years since 1928
2 to 5 yearsMostly short Treasuries, CDs or a Treasury ladder that matures on time; little or no stockShort bonds fell 3.9% in 2022, long ones far more
5+ yearsSome stocks plus short bonds, shifting to cash as the date nearsWorst 5-year result since 1950: −11.1% for stocks, +8.9% for 60/40

How much could a down payment lose in 1, 3 or 5 years?

Worst result of any calendar window from 1928 to 2025, before inflation, with each mix rebalanced every January and no fees or taxes (Exent calculation on NYU Stern’s annual returns; in brackets the window and how many windows lost money):

MixWorst 1 yearWorst 2 yearsWorst 3 yearsWorst 5 years
100% S&P 500−43.8% (1931; 26 of 98)−57.9% (1930–31; 16 of 97)−61.6% (1930–32; 15 of 96)−49.3% (1928–32; 11 of 94)
60% stocks / 40% 10-yr Treasuries−27.3% (1931; 21 of 98)−37.0% (1930–31; 17 of 97)−39.0% (1929–31; 9 of 96)−24.1% (1928–32; 4 of 94)
30% stocks / 70% 10-yr Treasuries−17.9% (2022; 15 of 98)−18.6% (1930–31; 8 of 97)−18.3% (1929–31; 7 of 96)−3.8% (1928–32; 3 of 94)
100% 10-yr Treasuries−17.8% (2022; 20 of 98)−21.5% (2021–22; 9 of 97)−18.4% (2021–23; 6 of 96)−13.5% (2021–25; 5 of 94)
100% 3-month T-bills0.0% (0 of 98)+0.1% (0 of 97)+0.1% (0 of 96)+0.3% (0 of 94)
  • 100% S&P 500
    Worst 1 year
    −43.8% (1931; 26 of 98)
    Worst 2 years
    −57.9% (1930–31; 16 of 97)
    Worst 3 years
    −61.6% (1930–32; 15 of 96)
    Worst 5 years
    −49.3% (1928–32; 11 of 94)
  • 60% stocks / 40% 10-yr Treasuries
    Worst 1 year
    −27.3% (1931; 21 of 98)
    Worst 2 years
    −37.0% (1930–31; 17 of 97)
    Worst 3 years
    −39.0% (1929–31; 9 of 96)
    Worst 5 years
    −24.1% (1928–32; 4 of 94)
  • 30% stocks / 70% 10-yr Treasuries
    Worst 1 year
    −17.9% (2022; 15 of 98)
    Worst 2 years
    −18.6% (1930–31; 8 of 97)
    Worst 3 years
    −18.3% (1929–31; 7 of 96)
    Worst 5 years
    −3.8% (1928–32; 3 of 94)
  • 100% 10-yr Treasuries
    Worst 1 year
    −17.8% (2022; 20 of 98)
    Worst 2 years
    −21.5% (2021–22; 9 of 97)
    Worst 3 years
    −18.4% (2021–23; 6 of 96)
    Worst 5 years
    −13.5% (2021–25; 5 of 94)
  • 100% 3-month T-bills
    Worst 1 year
    0.0% (0 of 98)
    Worst 2 years
    +0.1% (0 of 97)
    Worst 3 years
    +0.1% (0 of 96)
    Worst 5 years
    +0.3% (0 of 94)

Starting in 1950 instead removes the Depression and softens the stock rows: 100% stocks lost 36.6% in 2008, 37.4% over 2000–02 and 11.1% over 2000–04, and 60/40 lost 18.0% in 2022, 20.8% over 1973–74 and 11.0% over 1972–74, with no losing 5-year window. Three warnings. Calendar years hide deeper drops inside them: the S&P 500 ETF fell 56.5% from peak to trough in 2007–09 (Exent market data), far more than 2008’s −36.6%. “Bonds” here means 10-year Treasuries, which lost 21.5% over 2021–22, so a bond fund with a long maturity is not a safe parking place for money due in two years. And none of this includes inflation, which matters less over 2 years than over 20.

The pattern for 2 to 5 years shows up in fund data too. In calendar 2022, a 1–3 year Treasury fund (SHY) lost 3.9%, a 7–10 year Treasury fund (IEF) lost 15.2% and a T-bill fund (BIL) returned +1.4% (Exent market data). Maturity, not the word “bond”, decides how much a rate jump can cost.

Worked example: $60,000 needed in 3 years

Hypothetical saver: $53,000 today, $60,000 needed for a down payment and closing costs in 3 years. Reaching the goal takes +13.2% in total ($60,000 ÷ $53,000 − 1), or 4.22% a year. Three ways to hold the money, before taxes:

ChoiceArithmeticResult in 3 years
3-year Treasury at 4.72% (Oct 22, 2026), held to maturity$53,000 × 1.0472³About $60,900 under the illustration’s constant-rate annual-compounding assumption; actual terminal wealth depends on purchase terms and coupon reinvestment
T-bills rolled at 4.22%, if yields stayed put$53,000 × 1.0422³About $60,000; the yield resets every few months, up or down
100% S&P 500, past 3-year windows since 1928$53,000 × (1 + window return)Fell short of $60,000 in 20 of 96 windows; worst $20,362 (1930–32); median $73,156
60% stocks / 40% 10-yr Treasuries, same windows$53,000 × (1 + window return)Fell short in 21 of 96 windows; worst $32,309 (1929–31); median $68,413
30% stocks / 70% 10-yr Treasuries, same windows$53,000 × (1 + window return)Fell short in 24 of 96 windows; worst $43,311 (1929–31); median $63,447
  • 3-year Treasury at 4.72%, modeled≈ $60,900
  • Worst 3 years, 30/70$43,311
  • Worst 3 years, 60/40$32,309
  • Worst 3 years, 100% stocks$20,362

Read the table carefully. Adding bonds barely changed how often the saver missed $60,000 (20, 21 and 24 of 96 windows), because a 13.2% target is a high bar for any mix in a bad stretch. It changed how badly: the worst miss shrank from $39,638 short with 100% stocks to $16,689 short with 30/70. Since 1950, 100% stocks fell short in 11 of 74 windows, with a worst of $33,164 (2000–02). The windows overlap, so the 96 are not 96 independent tests. The Treasury rows show yields on one day; Treasury bill interest is federally taxable but exempt from state and local income tax (TreasuryDirect), which helps in high-tax states. For how the T-bill funds differ, see SGOV vs BIL vs SHV.

Where do people keep a down payment they will need soon?

In places whose value on the purchase date is either insured or set by a maturity date. Dated rates, which change monthly:

WhereRateAs ofProtection and catch
3-month Treasury bill4.22%Oct 22, 2026US government obligation; not FDIC-insured; no state income tax on the interest
3-year Treasury note4.72%Oct 22, 2026Coupons and principal fixed if held to maturity; the price moves if you sell early
National average 12-month CD1.76%Oct 19, 2026FDIC-insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per bank, per ownership category; early-withdrawal penalty
National average savings account0.38%Oct 19, 2026FDIC-insured; many banks pay well above the average

Sources: Federal Reserve yields via FRED DGS3MO and DGS3, and the FDIC’s national rates. A Treasury or CD ladder matches maturities to the expected closing date (see bond ladder vs bond fund); a large balance parked for a short time is covered in where to park a large amount of cash.

Many buyers also draw on other assets. In the National Association of Realtors’ 2025 survey (purchases July 2024 to June 2025), first-time buyers were 40 at the median and put down 10%; 59% used savings, 26% used financial assets such as a 401(k), stocks or crypto, and 22% used gifts or loans from family (NAR). Retirement money has its own rules: an early IRA distribution of up to $10,000 (a lifetime limit) for a qualified first-time home purchase avoids the 10% additional tax, but regular income tax still applies to the taxable part (IRS Topic 557). 401(k) loans and hardship withdrawals depend on the plan.

How do people move a down payment from stocks to cash?

Gradually and on a schedule set in advance, so a market drop does not decide the timing. A hypothetical glide path for a purchase about 6 years away, for illustration only:

Years to purchaseIllustrative stock shareRest held inHistorical worst for that horizon (1950–2025)
6+30%–60%Short Treasuries, CDs60/40: worst 5 years +8.9%; 30/70: +8.6%
3–50%–30%Treasuries or CDs maturing near the date30/70: worst 3 years −4.3% (2021–23)
Under 20%T-bills, insured savings, CDsT-bills: no losing year since 1928

The worst-case column uses 10-year Treasuries as the bond part; short Treasuries would have lost less in 2021–23, when longer yields jumped. Once the purchase is under contract, the usual practice is to hold the closing amount in cash; the hub on structuring a portfolio by goal and time horizon shows how this bucket sits next to retirement money and the emergency reserve.

When is keeping it all in cash the wrong call?

When the date is soft and the money could become long-term money. Counterexample: someone saving $53,000 with no fixed plan to buy, who might rent for 10 more years, is not really holding a down payment. Over 3-year windows since 1928 the median 100%-stock result turned $53,000 into $73,156, against roughly $60,000 at today’s T-bill yield; over long stretches cash also lags inflation. The opposite mistake is more common, though: treating money for a purchase next spring as an investment and finding it 20% lower when the right house comes up. If the purchase date can slide by years without regret, the horizon is longer than it looks; if it cannot, the table of worst cases is the one that applies.

  • Limitations: US calendar-year data, one lump sum per window, no fees or taxes, 10-year Treasuries as the only bond series; intra-year drops were deeper.
  • Overlapping windows: 96 three-year windows contain far fewer independent periods.
  • Yields and FDIC averages are dated Oct 19–22, 2026 and change often; T-bill yields reset as bills mature.
  • Mixes and glide paths are hypothetical illustrations, not advice; taxes, your income and how firm the date is change the answer.

Add market context with Exent Market intel

Market intel provides market context, cross‑asset analysis, an events calendar and regular written notes. These can inform your review of an existing plan; they do not reliably predict crashes or guarantee better outcomes.

  1. An events calendar with the data releases and central-bank meetings that move Treasury yields and mortgage rates.
  2. A Risk ON, Neutral or Risk OFF reading of US market risk built from four pillars, with an email when the reading changes, as background for the long-term part of your money.
  3. Regular written notes on cross‑asset ratios such as stocks vs bonds, and 26 Market Intel 101 lessons on rates and bonds.

Exent is our product. Educational content, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

Historically that was risky: the S&P 500 lost money in 26 of 98 calendar years since 1928, including −36.6% in 2008. Savers with a fixed date usually use insured savings, CDs or T-bills (3-month yield 4.22% on Oct 22, 2026).

Commonly in Treasuries or CDs that mature near the purchase date. A 3-year Treasury yielded 4.72% on Oct 22, 2026; a 1–3 year Treasury fund lost 3.9% in 2022, while 10-year Treasuries lost 17.8%.

It is FDIC-insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per bank, per ownership category, so the balance is protected. The national average savings rate was 0.38% on Oct 19, 2026, so it pays to compare with T-bills and online banks.

Not if you hold a bill to maturity: you receive its face value. A T-bill fund can move slightly in price, and 3-month T-bills had no losing calendar year from 1928 to 2025 before inflation.

Both, in separate buckets: money for the house in safe, dated places, and long-term money invested. In the worked example, $53,000 in 100% stocks missed a $60,000 three-year goal in 20 of 96 past windows.

Up to $10,000 (a lifetime limit) of early IRA distributions for a qualified first-time home purchase avoids the 10% additional tax, per IRS Topic 557, but regular income tax still applies to taxable amounts. 401(k) rules depend on the plan.

Usually by splitting it: the expected down payment in T-bills, CDs or Treasuries maturing on time, and only the rest invested for the long term. A 60/40 mix lost 39.0% over 1929–31 in the worst 3-year window.

They are usually kept separate, and both are short-term money. How large a reserve to hold and where people keep it is covered in the guide on how much cash to keep.

Sources

Add market context to your plan.

Market intel provides a Risk ON / Neutral / Risk OFF reading from four pillars, cross-asset analysis, an events calendar and regular written notes. Context for reviewing a plan, not a crash forecast.

See what Market intel includesLimited offer67% off your first month

Educational content, not investment advice. Examples are illustrative; past performance does not guarantee future results.

DISCLAIMER: Exent AI is an informational research platform and does not provide investment advice, financial advice, or act as an investment adviser, broker-dealer, or fiduciary. All content, analytics, and model outputs are provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any financial instrument. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Exent AI does not execute trades, hold customer funds, or provide brokerage services. Past performance and hypothetical results are not indicative of future results. Third-party data and AI-generated outputs may be incomplete or inaccurate.