ResourcesGuide

How to Take Retirement Withdrawals in a Bear Market

When the market is down 20% and you still need your monthly income, where the money comes from matters more than almost anything else. Here is the order many retirees use, what the research says about cutting back, and a worked 2022‑style example.

Published Updated 6 min readHow we research

Key takeaways

  • In a bear market, fund withdrawals from cash and short-term holdings first, then from whatever is above its target weight, and sell stocks last. The goal is to avoid selling stocks after a big fall.
  • You rarely need to stop withdrawals entirely. Research on flexible rules (Guyton and Klinger, 2006) relies on modest moves: skip the inflation raise after a losing year and cut about 10% only if the withdrawal rate drifts well above where it started.
  • In 2022 the S&P 500 fell 18.2% and the AGG bond ETF 13.0%, while T-bills (BIL) gained 1.4% (Exent’s data). A cash bucket was the one part of a classic mix that held up.
  • Illustrative: a $1.5M retiree drawing $60,000 who kept $150,000 in T-bills could fund the whole 2022 withdrawal without selling stocks or bonds at a loss.

What is your own portfolio exposed to? Check it with Exent →

How do I take withdrawals from my portfolio during a bear market?

Take the money from the parts of the portfolio that have not fallen, and leave stocks alone until they recover. Selling stocks after a 20% or 30% fall locks in the loss on those shares. Any shares you sell near the bottom cannot take part in the rebound.

A common order of sources when markets are down:

  • 1. Cash and T-bills set aside for spending (a “cash bucket”).
  • 2. Dividends and interest paid in cash instead of reinvested.
  • 3. Short-term, high-quality bonds that held their value.
  • 4. Any asset that is now above its target weight, which usually means bonds or cash after stocks fall.
  • 5. Stocks last, and preferably those with losses you can harvest in a taxable account.

This mirrors the withdrawal order in Guyton and Klinger’s 2006 study: overweight assets first, then cash, then bonds, with no withdrawals from an equity class after a year in which it lost money.

What would a 2022‑style year do to a $1.5M retiree?

The source of the withdrawal decided how much damage 2022 did. Illustrative: a $1.5 million portfolio that needs $60,000 a year (4%), using 2022 calendar returns from Exent’s data as of Sep 30, 2026.

HoldingStart of 20222022 returnEnd of 2022
Stocks (SPY)$900,000−18.2%$736,200
Bonds (AGG)$450,000−13.0%$391,500
T-bills (BIL)$150,000+1.4%$152,100
Total$1,500,000−14.7%$1,279,800

Taking the $60,000 from the T-bill bucket left stocks and bonds untouched at depressed prices. Without the bucket, a plain 60/40 mix of SPY and AGG would have ended the year at $1,258,200, and the withdrawal would have meant selling one of two assets that were both down. Illustrative only, not a forecast. Bonds do not always fall with stocks; in 2022 they did, which is why the 60/40 debate restarted.

Should I stop withdrawing when the market is down 20%?

Usually not. Most retirees cannot stop, and the research suggests small, rule-based adjustments do most of the work. In Guyton and Klinger’s rules, two adjustments matter in a downturn:

  • No inflation raise after a losing year, if your current withdrawal rate is above your starting rate. The missed raise is not made up later.
  • A 10% cut only if the current withdrawal rate has risen more than 20% above the starting rate, for example above 6% for someone who started at 5%.

Morningstar’s research points the same way. Its December 2025 report put the starting safe withdrawal rate for fixed, inflation-adjusted spending at 3.9% (30 years, 90% probability of success) and found that flexible methods such as guardrails supported higher starting rates. See Morningstar’s summary.

Adjustment on a $60,000 withdrawal (Illustrative)Saved this year
Skip a 3% inflation raise$1,800
Cut 10%$6,000
Cut travel and big purchases only, keep essentialsDepends on your budget

The full rule set is in our guide to the guardrails withdrawal strategy.

How big should my cash bucket be?

Big enough to cover the withdrawals you would need while stocks recover, but not so big that inflation erodes too much of the portfolio. Retirees often think of it in years of spending. Illustrative: two years of $60,000 is $120,000, or 8% of a $1.5M portfolio.

Recoveries have varied a lot. The S&P 500 fell 25.4% peak to trough in the 2022 bear market in Exent’s data, and some past declines took years to recover. Our crash recovery time guide shows how long each took, and how much cash to hold covers the trade-off with inflation.

What mistakes do retirees make in a down market?

  • Selling stocks first because that is where the money is. It feels efficient and turns a paper loss into a permanent one.
  • Moving everything to cash. It ends the pain and often misses the rebound. See should I go to cash?
  • Refilling the cash bucket too soon. Refill it from gains after stocks recover, not by selling them at the low.
  • Ignoring taxes. Losses in a taxable account can be harvested; withdrawals from an IRA are taxed as income whatever the market does.

What should I check this weekend?

  • Write down your yearly withdrawal and how many months of it sit in cash or T-bills today.
  • Split your spending into essentials and items you could pause for a year.
  • Calculate your current withdrawal rate: this year’s withdrawal divided by today’s portfolio value.
  • Note which holdings are above and below target weight, so you know where the next withdrawal should come from.
  • Replay a 2008 or 2022 drop on your holdings and compare the dollar loss with your cash bucket.

How to test a down year on your portfolio with Exent

  1. Upload a screenshot or file of your holdings (CSV, Excel, PDF or Google Sheet); no brokerage login.
  2. Exent replays the portfolio through 2008, 2018, 2020, 2022 and 2025 and shows the dollar loss and which positions drive it.
  3. Add a cash or T-bill position in the what‑if simulator to see how a bigger bucket changes the crash loss before you move anything.

Exent is our product. Educational content, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

Most retirees keep withdrawing but change where the money comes from: cash and short-term holdings first, stocks last. Small spending adjustments, such as skipping an inflation raise, have historically helped more than stopping completely.

Cash and T-bills set aside for spending, then dividends and interest, then short-term bonds or whatever is above its target weight. Stocks that have fallen are usually sold last.

Rule-based approaches such as Guyton-Klinger skip the inflation raise after a losing year and cut about 10% only when the withdrawal rate has risen more than 20% above where it started.

Not much. In Exent’s data the AGG bond ETF lost 13.0% in 2022 while the S&P 500 lost 18.2%. T-bills held through BIL gained 1.4%.

It is money kept in cash or T-bills to cover a set number of years of withdrawals, so you do not have to sell stocks after a fall. Its size is a trade-off between protection and the drag of holding cash.

See what your portfolio is really made of.

Upload a screenshot of your holdings and get concentration, overlap, crash exposure and a risk-matched benchmark in about a minute.

Check my portfolioLimited offer$1.95 for unlimited checks· unlimited checks

Educational content, not investment advice. Examples are illustrative; past performance does not guarantee future results.

DISCLAIMER: Exent AI is an informational research platform and does not provide investment advice, financial advice, or act as an investment adviser, broker-dealer, or fiduciary. All content, analytics, and model outputs are provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any financial instrument. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Exent AI does not execute trades, hold customer funds, or provide brokerage services. Past performance and hypothetical results are not indicative of future results. Third-party data and AI-generated outputs may be incomplete or inaccurate.