ResourcesGuide

What Stock Screener Settings Work for Long‑Term Investors?

The handful of screener filters long-term investors use most, why each one exists, sensible starting values, and how factor screens have actually performed over the past decade.

Published Updated 5 min readHow we research

Key takeaways

  • Long-term screens usually combine five to seven filters: a minimum size, profitability, positive free cash flow, manageable debt, a valuation cap, and optionally a trend or momentum filter.
  • Fewer filters generalize better. Every extra rule fits the past more closely and makes the list more fragile.
  • Factor screens are cyclical. In Exent’s backtest from Jul 2016 to Sep 2026, momentum, quality, value and minimum-volatility ETFs all had lower Sharpe ratios than the S&P 500 fund.
  • A screen produces candidates, not buys. Check each name’s thesis, valuation and fit with your portfolio.

Which stocks do Wall Street’s best‑ranked analysts agree on? See them in Exent Gems →

Which screener filters matter most for long-term investors?

The filters that matter most test whether a company makes money, turns it into cash, can survive a bad year, and is not priced for perfection. The values below are illustrative starting points to adjust, not rules.

FilterIllustrative starting valueWhy it is thereWatch out for
Market capAbove $2 billionLiquidity, data quality, fewer blow-upsExcludes small caps entirely
Gross or operating marginPositive and stable for 3+ yearsProfitable businesses tend to compoundMargins at a cyclical peak
Free cash flowPositive over the last 12 monthsEarnings backed by cashHeavy-investment growth companies fail it
DebtNet debt below about 3× operating cash flowSurvives higher rates and recessionsBanks and utilities need sector rules
ValuationForward P/E below its 5-year average or sector medianAvoids paying for perfectionCheap can mean shrinking
TrendPrice above its 200-day moving averageAvoids stocks in persistent declineWhipsaws in sideways markets
Revenue growthPositive over 3 yearsScreens out shrinking businessesAcquisitions can flatter growth

Illustrative values only. They are a common way to start, not a tested formula. Related terms: free cash flow, forward P/E and the 200-day moving average.

Do these filters have evidence behind them?

Some do. Novy-Marx (2013) found gross profitability predicted stock returns about as well as book-to-market value, and that profitable firms earned higher returns despite higher valuations. Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) found recent winners kept outperforming recent losers over three to twelve months. These are the academic roots of the quality and momentum factors.

But effects fade once they are known. McLean and Pontiff (2016) studied 97 published return predictors and found their returns were 26% lower out of sample and 58% lower after publication. A filter with a famous paper behind it is a reasonable input, not an edge.

How have factor screens done recently?

Mixed. Exent backtested the factor ETFs that package these screens against the S&P 500 fund (SPY) from Jul 2016 to Sep 2026:

Strategy (ETF)Annual returnSharpe ratioMax drawdown2022
S&P 500 (SPY)15.2%0.88−23.9%−18.2%
Momentum (MTUM)16.2%0.81−30.2%−18.3%
Quality (QUAL)14.2%0.81−27.8%−20.5%
Value (IVE)11.4%0.66−25.3%−5.4%
Minimum volatility (USMV)9.4%0.63−19.1%−9.4%
  • S&P 500 (SPY)
    Annual return
    15.2%
    Sharpe ratio
    0.88
    Max drawdown
    −23.9%
    2022
    −18.2%
  • Momentum (MTUM)
    Annual return
    16.2%
    Sharpe ratio
    0.81
    Max drawdown
    −30.2%
    2022
    −18.3%
  • Quality (QUAL)
    Annual return
    14.2%
    Sharpe ratio
    0.81
    Max drawdown
    −27.8%
    2022
    −20.5%
  • Value (IVE)
    Annual return
    11.4%
    Sharpe ratio
    0.66
    Max drawdown
    −25.3%
    2022
    −5.4%
  • Minimum volatility (USMV)
    Annual return
    9.4%
    Sharpe ratio
    0.63
    Max drawdown
    −19.1%
    2022
    −9.4%

Momentum beat the index on return but with deeper falls; none beat it on Sharpe ratio over this decade, which was dominated by a few mega-cap growth stocks. Value and minimum volatility did their job in 2022, falling far less. A screen tilts you toward a type of stock that wins in some periods and lags in others. Each strategy has a page, for example momentum.

How many filters should a stock screen have?

Usually five to seven. Each extra rule shrinks the list and makes it fit the recent past more tightly. If you tune ten filters until the results look great over the last five years, you have described the last five years, not found a method. That is backtest overfitting. A simple test: change each threshold by 20% in either direction. If the list changes completely, the screen is fragile.

Example screens for long-term investors

Screen (illustrative)FiltersWhat it tends to find
Quality compounderMarket cap > $2B, operating margin stable or rising 5 years, positive free cash flow, net debt < 2× cash flowSteady, often expensive businesses
Reasonable valueMarket cap > $2B, forward P/E below sector median, positive free cash flow, revenue growingCheaper companies that are not shrinking
Quality with trendQuality compounder filters + price above 200-day moving averageStrong businesses the market is currently rewarding

Illustrative examples to adapt, not recommendations or tested strategies.

Common stock screener mistakes

  • Screening only on low P/E: it catches value traps, companies that are cheap because earnings are about to fall.
  • Ignoring sector clumping: many screens return ten names from one industry, which is one bet, not ten.
  • Backtesting on today’s stock list: it leaves out companies that went bust, which flatters every screen (survivorship bias).
  • Changing filters every month: you end up chasing whatever just worked.
  • Skipping portfolio fit: a perfect screen result can still double a risk you already carry.

What to do with the screen results

Read the shortlist one name at a time. Write a one-line thesis, check valuation and crash history, and see how each name would change your portfolio’s correlation and concentration. Our guides on evaluating a stock idea and value traps cover those steps.

How to run a screen with Exent

  1. Describe the filters in plain English in the Stocks Radar screener (for example “profitable, positive free cash flow, below its sector P/E”) instead of setting each field.
  2. Check each result’s analyst ratings, price targets and insider activity, with analysts ranked by past accuracy.
  3. Before buying, add a candidate in the Portfolio Analysis what‑if simulator to see how it changes correlation and concentration.

Exent is our product. Educational content, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

Start with four filters: a minimum market cap for liquidity, positive free cash flow, manageable debt, and a valuation cap compared with the sector. Add more only when you know what each one is for.

There is no universal number. Comparing a company’s forward P/E with its own history and its sector median works better than a fixed cutoff, because normal valuations differ widely between industries.

Some investors add a trend filter, such as price above the 200-day moving average, to avoid stocks in persistent decline. Momentum has academic support but has had deep drawdowns, and in Exent’s backtest the momentum ETF fell 30.2% at its worst from 2016 to 2026.

Not by themselves. Factor screens go through long periods of lagging the index; over 2016 to 2026 none of the major factor ETFs beat the S&P 500 fund on Sharpe ratio in Exent’s backtest.

Enough to research properly, often 10 to 30 names. If a screen returns hundreds, add a filter; if it returns two, loosen one.

Get the picks Wall Street’s best analysts agree on.

Exent tracks 4,000+ analysts, keeps only the elite few with proven records, and surfaces the Gems where they agree.

See this week’s GemsLimited offer$1.95 for full access· full access

Educational content, not investment advice. Examples are illustrative; past performance does not guarantee future results.

DISCLAIMER: Exent AI is an informational research platform and does not provide investment advice, financial advice, or act as an investment adviser, broker-dealer, or fiduciary. All content, analytics, and model outputs are provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any financial instrument. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Exent AI does not execute trades, hold customer funds, or provide brokerage services. Past performance and hypothetical results are not indicative of future results. Third-party data and AI-generated outputs may be incomplete or inaccurate.