CompareComparison

Conservative vs Moderate vs Aggressive Portfolio: 98 Years Compared

Three hypothetical mixes of US stocks and 10-year Treasuries, 30/70, 60/40 and 90/10, tested on the same annual data from 1928 to 2025: return, worst year, worst fall, years to recover and who each one tends to fit.

Published Updated 8 min readHow we research

Disclosure: Exent publishes this page and makes one of the products discussed. Facts about other products are checked on their own sites and dated. Our editorial policy explains how.

Key takeaways

  • More stock bought more growth and deeper falls. From 1928 to 2025, hypothetical 30/70, 60/40 and 90/10 stock/Treasury mixes returned 6.6%, 8.3% and 9.7% a year (Exent calculation on NYU Stern data, yearly rebalancing, no fees or taxes).
  • Worst calendar year: −17.9% (2022), −27.3% (1931) and −39.7% (1931). Worst fall in year-end value: −18.6%, −40.1% and −59.4%, recovered in 5, 7 and 8 years.
  • Conservative was not safe from inflation: after inflation, 30/70 lost 33.4% from 1972 to 1981 and took until 1985 to recover, 13 years.
  • In 2022 all three lost about the same (−17.9% to −18.0%) because stocks and Treasuries fell together.
  • Labels differ by firm. Compare the stock share, the worst year you could sit through and when you need the money, not the word on the model.

Market risk reading, cross‑asset context and an events calendar: see Exent Market intel →

What is the difference between a conservative, moderate and aggressive portfolio?

Mainly the share in stocks. A conservative portfolio holds mostly bonds and cash, a moderate one balances the two, and an aggressive one is mostly stocks. That one number decides most of the long-run return and most of the historically observed loss. The SEC’s beginners’ guide to asset allocation puts the choice down to two things: how long until you need the money, and your ability and willingness to take losses.

Scope. Three hypothetical illustrations, not model portfolios of any firm and not advice: Conservative = 30% S&P 500 / 70% 10-year Treasuries, Moderate = 60/40, Aggressive = 90/10. Data: annual US total returns 1928–2025 (NYU Stern, Damodaran), rebalanced every January, no fees, taxes or trading costs. Not covered: international stocks, corporate bonds, cash buckets and withdrawals in retirement.

How did the three mixes compare from 1928 to 2025?

1928–2025 (98 years)Conservative 30/70Moderate 60/40Aggressive 90/10
Return a year (compound)6.6%8.3%9.7%
After inflation3.5%5.1%6.4%
Worst calendar year−17.9% (2022)−27.3% (1931)−39.7% (1931)
Losing years15 of 9821 of 9826 of 98
Worst 3 years, total−18.3% (1929–31)−39.0% (1929–31)−56.4% (1929–31)
Worst fall in year-end value−18.6% (end-1929 to end-1931)−40.1% (end-1928 to end-1932)−59.4% (end-1928 to end-1932)
Years from that peak back to it5 (by end-1934)7 (by end-1935)8 (by end-1936)
Worst fall after inflation−33.4% (1972–81; back in 1985)−35.2% (1972–74; back in 1985)−48.9% (1928–31; back in 1935)
Worst 10 years, a year+3.0% (1965–74)+1.8% (1929–38)−0.6% (1929–38)
Growth of $10,000$5.4 million$25.7 million$84.7 million

Exent calculation; every figure is a hypothetical mix, not a fund’s record. Two things stand out. The extra return from each step up in stocks shrank (1.7 points a year from 30/70 to 60/40, 1.4 from 60/40 to 90/10), while the worst fall grew sharply. And the 98-year totals look enormous only because of compounding over a lifetime nobody invests for: no real investor held from 1928 to 2025 without adding, spending or paying fees.

  • Aggressive 90/10: worst fall in year-end value−59.4%
  • Moderate 60/40: worst fall in year-end value−40.1%
  • Conservative 30/70: worst fall in year-end value−18.6%

How did each mix do in the worst years?

Calendar-year results in four bad years for stocks (same calculation and data):

1931
1974
2008
2022
YearConservative 30/70Moderate 60/40Aggressive 90/10What happened
1931−14.9%−27.3%−39.7%Depression; stocks −43.8%, Treasuries −2.6%
1974−6.4%−14.7%−23.1%Inflation and recession; Treasuries +2.0%
2008+3.1%−13.9%−30.9%Financial crisis; Treasuries +20.1%
2022−17.9%−18.0%−18.0%Inflation and rate rises; stocks −18.0%, Treasuries −17.8%
  • 1931
    Conservative 30/70
    −14.9%
    Moderate 60/40
    −27.3%
    Aggressive 90/10
    −39.7%
    What happened
    Depression; stocks −43.8%, Treasuries −2.6%
  • 1974
    Conservative 30/70
    −6.4%
    Moderate 60/40
    −14.7%
    Aggressive 90/10
    −23.1%
    What happened
    Inflation and recession; Treasuries +2.0%
  • 2008
    Conservative 30/70
    +3.1%
    Moderate 60/40
    −13.9%
    Aggressive 90/10
    −30.9%
    What happened
    Financial crisis; Treasuries +20.1%
  • 2022
    Conservative 30/70
    −17.9%
    Moderate 60/40
    −18.0%
    Aggressive 90/10
    −18.0%
    What happened
    Inflation and rate rises; stocks −18.0%, Treasuries −17.8%

The bond side earned its place in 2008, when 10-year Treasuries rose 20.1% and the conservative mix gained. In 2022 it did not: both sides fell, and the three labels ended up within 0.1 point of each other. A conservative mix built only on longer Treasuries protects against recessions better than against inflation (see do bonds still hedge stocks? and is 60/40 dead?).

Do the results depend on the start year?

Yes, a lot. The same three mixes over shorter windows ending in 2025:

PeriodConservative 30/70Moderate 60/40Aggressive 90/10
1928–2025: return / worst year6.6% / −17.9%8.3% / −27.3%9.7% / −39.7%
1950–20257.3% / −17.9%9.4% / −18.0%11.1% / −30.9%
1972–20257.8% / −17.9%9.4% / −18.0%10.7% / −30.9%
2000–20255.6% / −17.9%6.9% / −18.0%7.8% / −30.9%

Since 2000 the gap between moderate and aggressive was under 1 point a year, because the period began with the 2000–02 bear market and included 2008. Starting dates are luck, which is why the worst cases matter more than the averages. For the same kind of test on All Weather–style mixes, see All Weather, Permanent and Golden Butterfly.

Who does each portfolio tend to fit?

Illustrative fitConservative 30/70Moderate 60/40Aggressive 90/10
Money neededFlexible spending over several years; near-term essential withdrawals separately reserved in cash or maturity-matched assetsIn about 7–15 years, or a mix of near and far goals15+ years away
A fall you would sit throughAbout 20%About 40%About 60%
Historical recovery to sit through5 years nominal; 13 after inflation in the 1970s7 years nominal8 years nominal
Main riskInflation and rising ratesBoth sides falling, as in 2022Deep falls and selling at the bottom

These are illustrations, not a questionnaire. The deciding question is behavioural: would you keep the mix through its worst historical fall, without selling? An aggressive mix that is abandoned at −40% ends up worse than a moderate one that is held. See how much of a drop you can tolerate, asset allocation by age and, for households where two people see risk differently, couples with different risk tolerance.

When is this comparison wrong for you?

When “conservative” is chosen to feel safe but the money is long-term. Counterexample: a 35-year-old who picks 30/70 for a retirement 30 years away gave up 3.1 points a year against 90/10 over 1928–2025 and, in the 1970s, still lost a third of its value after inflation. The reverse also fails: a retiree drawing income from a 90/10 mix may have to sell stocks after a 40% fall (see sequence-of-returns risk). And the labels hide what is inside: a 60/40 built with long bonds and a few stocks is a different risk from a 60/40 of broad index funds and short Treasuries.

  • Limitations: US stocks and 10-year Treasuries only; calendar-year data, so intra-year falls were deeper; one lump sum, no contributions or withdrawals.
  • No fees or taxes; yearly rebalancing assumed. Real funds and accounts would show lower returns.
  • The US was one of the century’s best-performing markets, and others had longer recoveries, so US history may flatter every row.
  • The three mixes are hypothetical illustrations; they do not reproduce any firm’s model portfolio and are not advice.

Add market context with Exent Market intel

Market intel provides market context, cross‑asset analysis, an events calendar and regular written notes. These can inform your review of an existing plan; they do not reliably predict crashes or guarantee better outcomes.

  1. A Risk ON, Neutral or Risk OFF reading of US market risk built from four pillars, with an email when the reading changes.
  2. Cross‑asset correlations, including how stocks and bonds have been moving together, which decides whether the bond side is cushioning a mix.
  3. Regular written notes on cross‑asset ratios such as stocks vs bonds, and 26 Market Intel 101 lessons.

Exent is our product. Educational content, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

There is no standard definition; firms label their own mixes. This page uses 60/40 as the moderate example: 60% S&P 500 / 40% 10-year Treasuries returned 8.3% a year from 1928 to 2025 with a worst year of −27.3% (1931), as a hypothetical mix with no fees.

There is no standard split, so check the stock share behind the label. The 30/70 mix here returned 6.6% a year from 1928 to 2025, lost 17.9% in 2022 and had 15 losing years out of 98.

The hypothetical 90/10 mix lost 39.7% in 1931 and 30.9% in 2008; its year-end value fell 59.4% from 1928 to 1932 and took until 1936 to recover.

Safer from stock crashes, not from inflation or rising rates. The 30/70 mix lost 17.9% in 2022 and, after inflation, 33.4% from 1972 to 1981.

Not better, riskier. On the same 1928–2025 data a hypothetical 80/20 mix returned 9.3% a year against 8.3% for 60/40, but lost 35.6% in its worst year (1931, vs −27.3%) and 53.5% at its deepest year-end fall (vs −40.1%). Whether the extra point a year is worth it depends on your horizon and how you react to losses.

In this test, measured on year-end values, the worst falls took 5 years to recover for 30/70, 7 for 60/40 and 8 for 90/10, all after the 1929–32 crash.

That depends on when you need the money and the worst loss you would hold through. The SEC’s asset-allocation guide names time horizon and risk tolerance as the two main factors; this page is education, not a recommendation.

Stocks fell 18.0% and 10-year Treasuries 17.8% that year, so the mix of the two barely mattered. Both fell in the same calendar year only 5 times from 1928 to 2025: 1931, 1941, 1969, 2018 and 2022.

Sources

  1. Historical Returns on Stocks, Bonds and Bills: 1928–2025 (histretSP) — NYU Stern School of Business, Aswath Damodaran, Aug 24, 2026
  2. Beginners’ Guide to Asset Allocation, Diversification, and Rebalancing — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (Investor.gov)

Add market context to your plan.

Market intel provides a Risk ON / Neutral / Risk OFF reading from four pillars, cross-asset analysis, an events calendar and regular written notes. Context for reviewing a plan, not a crash forecast.

See what Market intel includesLimited offer67% off your first month

Educational content, not investment advice. Examples are illustrative; past performance does not guarantee future results.

DISCLAIMER: Exent AI is an informational research platform and does not provide investment advice, financial advice, or act as an investment adviser, broker-dealer, or fiduciary. All content, analytics, and model outputs are provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any financial instrument. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Exent AI does not execute trades, hold customer funds, or provide brokerage services. Past performance and hypothetical results are not indicative of future results. Third-party data and AI-generated outputs may be incomplete or inaccurate.