# SPY vs the S&P 500: Why Your Return Isn’t the Index Return

> SPY is the oldest fund that tracks the S&P 500, but the fund and the index are not the same thing. How closely SPY has followed the index, why it trails it, and why the number in the headlines is often the wrong comparison.

Source: https://www.exent.ai/resources/spy-vs-sp-500-index · Reviewed by David, Senior Analyst, Exent · Published Oct 27, 2026 · Updated Oct 27, 2026

> Disclosure: Exent publishes this page and makes one of the products discussed. Facts about other products are checked on their own sites and dated. Our editorial policy explains how.

## Key takeaways

- SPY tracks the S&P 500 closely but trails it slightly: 15.18% a year over the 10 years to Sep 30, 2026 at NAV, against 15.33% for the index with dividends (State Street fact sheet).
- About 0.09 points of that 0.15-point yearly gap is SPY’s 0.0945% expense ratio. The rest reflects the costs of running a real fund, such as trading and dividends held in cash until they are paid out.
- The S&P 500 in the headlines is usually the price index, without dividends. It fell 19.44% in 2022, while SPY’s total return was −18.2%. From 2016 to 2025 the price index rose 235%, SPY 295%.
- Cheaper twins track closer: VOO trailed the index by 0.04 points a year over the same 10 years (Vanguard).
- Your own return can differ again because of taxes on dividends, when you bought and sold, and whether payouts were reinvested.

## Is SPY the same as the S&P 500?

No. The S&P 500 is an index: a list of about 500 large US companies and a number calculated from their prices. You cannot buy it. SPY, the State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust launched in January 1993, is a fund that buys those stocks and, in the words of its fact sheet, seeks results that, before expenses, “correspond generally to the price and yield performance” of the index.

So SPY’s return is the index return minus the cost of being a real fund. The index pays no fees, never trades, and reinvests every dividend instantly on paper. A fund has to do all of that with real money. The difference is small for SPY, but it is never zero. Definitions: index fund and total return.

## How closely has SPY tracked the S&P 500?

Very closely, and slightly behind. Average annual total returns to Sep 30, 2026, from each issuer’s fact sheet, with the S&P 500 measured with dividends reinvested:

|  | 1 year | 3 years | 5 years | 10 years |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| S&P 500 Index (total return) | 15.74% | 22.89% | 13.79% | 15.33% |
| [SPY at NAV](https://www.exent.ai/etfs/spy) | 15.60% | 22.73% | 13.65% | 15.18% |
| SPY at market price | 15.66% | 22.73% | 13.66% | 15.18% |
| [VOO at NAV](https://www.exent.ai/etfs/voo) | 15.70% | 22.85% | 13.75% | 15.29% |
| SPY gap to the index, per year | −0.14 | −0.16 | −0.14 | −0.15 |
| VOO gap to the index, per year | −0.04 | −0.04 | −0.04 | −0.04 |

Sources: [SPY fact sheet](https://www.ssga.com/us/en/intermediary/library-content/products/factsheets/etfs/us/factsheet-us-en-spy.pdf) and [VOO fact sheet](https://fund-docs.vanguard.com/F0968.pdf), both as of Sep 30, 2026. The steady gap is called tracking difference. Its day-to-day wobble is tracking error. For SPY both are tiny; the point is that the gap is persistent and runs in one direction.

## Price return or total return: which S&P 500 number should you compare with?

The total return. News reports, charts and most apps quote the S&P 500 price index, which ignores dividends. Your SPY position earns dividends as well, so comparing it with the price index makes the fund look better than “the market” when it actually trailed it.

| Year | S&P 500 price index | SPY total return | Difference |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 2021 | +26.89% | +28.74% | +1.85 pts |
| 2022 | −19.44% | −18.17% | +1.27 pts |
| 2023 | +24.23% | +26.19% | +1.96 pts |
| 2024 | +23.31% | +24.89% | +1.58 pts |
| 2025 | +16.39% | +17.72% | +1.33 pts |
| 2016–2025, cumulative | +235% | +295% | +60 pts |

Price index: the calendar-year changes and year-end values (2,043.94 at the end of 2015, 6,845.50 at the end of 2025) in [SPY’s January 2026 prospectus](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/884394/000119312526023648/d935960d497.htm), sourced from S&P. SPY total return: Exent market data from daily closes with dividends reinvested. Over the decade the price index compounded at 12.8% a year and SPY at 14.7%. The difference is dividends: the index’s year-end dividend yield ranged from 1.15% to 2.14% over those years in the same prospectus table, and it was 1.10% on Sep 30, 2026 per the fact sheet.

## Why does SPY trail the total-return index?

Mostly fees, plus a few rules from its 1993 structure. SPY is a unit investment trust, and its prospectus dated Jan 26, 2026 sets out what that means:

- **The expense ratio.** 0.0945% a year, deducted from the fund every day. Over 10 years that explains about 0.09 of the 0.15-point gap. See expense ratio.
- **Dividends wait in cash.** Dividends from the 500 companies are credited to a non-interest-bearing account and paid out quarterly, on the last business day of April, July, October and January. The index treats them as reinvested at once. In a rising market, that idle cash is a small drag.
- **No securities lending.** The trustee may not lend the trust’s stocks, so SPY cannot earn the lending income some open-end funds use to offset costs.
- **Trading costs.** The prospectus notes that the fund’s return may not match the index because of expenses and the transaction costs of adjusting the portfolio when the index changes.

Each of these is a fraction of a percent. Together they explain why S&P 500 ETFs built as ordinary open-end funds with lower fees, such as VOO, trailed the index by less.

## Why might your own return differ from SPY’s?

Because published fund returns assume you bought at the start, reinvested every dividend and never sold. Real investors rarely do all three:

- **Dividends.** The trust itself provides no dividend reinvestment. Payouts land in your account as cash, and a broker may reinvest them for you, a few days after the index already has.
- **Taxes.** In a taxable account, dividends are taxed each year, which the published return ignores.
- **Timing.** Money added after a rise or pulled after a fall earns less than the fund. Morningstar’s [Mind the Gap 2026](https://www.morningstar.com/content/cs-assets/v3/assets/blt9415ea4cc4157833/blt852a4301adc2f5db/6a7373d51f7b5ae2da78e1e8/US_Mind_the_Gap_2026.pdf) found that the average dollar in US stock funds earned 12.8% a year over the decade to 2025, against 13.3% for the funds.
- **Price vs NAV.** You trade at the market price, which can sit slightly above or below the fund’s net asset value. For SPY the two were within 0.06 points a year over every period in the table above.

For the effect of taxes and fees on a full portfolio, see after-fee, after-tax returns.

## SPY vs VOO, IVV and SPYM: does the tracking gap matter?

A little, over long periods. Applying the published 10-year annual rates to $100,000 shows the size of it (arithmetic on past returns, not a forecast):

|  | 10-year return a year | $100,000 after 10 years | Behind the index |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| S&P 500 Index (total return) | 15.33% | $416,316 | — |
| VOO at NAV | 15.29% | $414,874 | −$1,442 |
| SPY at NAV | 15.18% | $410,933 | −$5,383 |

On a large balance held for decades that gap compounds; for a trader who values SPY’s deep trading volume and options market, it may be a fair price. Selling SPY with big gains in a taxable account to save the difference usually costs more in tax than it saves. The full fund-by-fund comparison, including fees, structure and liquidity, is in [VOO vs IVV vs SPY vs SPYM](https://www.exent.ai/compare/voo-vs-ivv-vs-spy-vs-spym); for the wider index question see [VOO vs VTI](https://www.exent.ai/compare/voo-vs-vti).

## How to compare a fund or portfolio with the S&P 500 fairly

- Use the total-return S&P 500, not the price index, whenever your holdings pay dividends.
- Compare over the same dates, and over several periods: 1, 5 and 10 years.
- Compare at NAV for the fund’s own record, and use your account’s money-weighted return for what you actually earned.
- Subtract the fees you pay on top, such as an advisory fee, before declaring a winner.
- Judge a portfolio that is not 100% US large-cap stocks against a benchmark with similar risk, not against the S&P 500 alone.

## How to compare your portfolio with the right benchmark in Exent

1. Upload a screenshot of your holdings (or a CSV, Excel, PDF or Google Sheet); no brokerage login.
2. Exent compares the portfolio with a risk‑matched benchmark and reports Sharpe, Sortino, Calmar and maximum drawdown.
3. Correlation clusters show funds that move together, so SPY, VOO and IVV held side by side show up as one bet, not three.

Exent is our product: [Exent portfolio check](https://www.exent.ai/portfolio)

## Frequently asked questions

### SPY vs S&P 500: is SPY the same as the index?

No. The S&P 500 is an index you cannot buy; SPY is a fund that holds its stocks. Over the 10 years to Sep 30, 2026, SPY returned 15.18% a year at NAV against 15.33% for the index with dividends.

### Why is SPY’s return lower than the S&P 500?

Mainly its 0.0945% expense ratio. Its trust structure also holds dividends in a non-interest-bearing account until quarterly payouts, cannot lend securities, and pays trading costs the index does not.

### Does the S&P 500 return include dividends?

The headline S&P 500 is a price index and excludes dividends. The total-return version includes them; it is the one fund fact sheets use, and it is the fair comparison for SPY.

### How much did the S&P 500 fall in 2022?

The price index fell 19.44% in 2022, per the index history in SPY’s prospectus. With dividends, SPY’s total return was −18.2% in Exent’s market data.

### Is VOO closer to the S&P 500 than SPY?

Yes, slightly. Over the 10 years to Sep 30, 2026, VOO trailed the index by 0.04 points a year and SPY by 0.15, mostly because VOO’s expense ratio is 0.03% against 0.0945%.

## Sources

1. [State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) fact sheet](https://www.ssga.com/us/en/intermediary/library-content/products/factsheets/etfs/us/factsheet-us-en-spy.pdf) — State Street Global Advisors, 2026-09-30
2. [SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust prospectus (Form 497)](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/884394/000119312526023648/d935960d497.htm) — SEC EDGAR, 2026-01-26
3. [Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO) fact sheet](https://fund-docs.vanguard.com/F0968.pdf) — Vanguard, 2026-09-30
4. [Mind the Gap 2026](https://www.morningstar.com/content/cs-assets/v3/assets/blt9415ea4cc4157833/blt852a4301adc2f5db/6a7373d51f7b5ae2da78e1e8/US_Mind_the_Gap_2026.pdf) — Morningstar, 2026-08-06

---

Educational content, not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
