# Do Wall Street Analysts Beat the Market?

> What happens to stocks after analysts rate them, what the academic studies found once trading costs are counted, and which analysts did better than the rest.

Source: https://www.exent.ai/resources/do-analysts-beat-the-market · Reviewed by David, Senior Analyst, Exent · Published Nov 4, 2026 · Updated Nov 4, 2026

## Key takeaways

- Not reliably, on average. Classic research found top-rated stocks beat the market by over 4% a year before costs, but the trading needed to capture it left net returns not reliably above zero.
- In Exent’s 7-year backtest of 988,127 ratings, stocks rose over the next 12 months 64.4% of the time, with a median 12-month price return of +13.6%. That is a raw return, not a market-beating one.
- Averages hide the spread: 5★ analysts in Exent’s data had a median 12-month call return of +21.0% versus +12.4% for 4★, measured over the same history used to rate them.
- Professionals as a group struggle too: 79% of active US large-cap funds trailed the S&P 500 in 2025 (SPIVA).

## Does anyone beat the S&P 500 consistently?

Few do, and that is the right starting point. In 2025, 79% of actively managed US large-cap funds underperformed the S&P 500 index, according to S&P Dow Jones Indices’ [SPIVA U.S. Year-End 2025](https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/spiva/article/spiva-us-year-end-2025/) scorecard. Over longer periods the share that trails is higher still. Our guide to [why most investors can’t beat the S&P 500](https://www.exent.ai/resources/why-most-investors-cant-beat-the-sp-500) covers the reasons.

Analysts face the same headwind, plus one more: most of their ratings are buys. In Exent’s data 70.4% of recent ratings were Buy. A list where nearly everything is a buy cannot, as a whole, beat the market it mostly consists of.

## What do academic studies say about analyst picks?

The research finds some signal before costs and little after them. The best-known study used about 360,000 recommendations from 1986 to 1996.

| Study | Finding |
| --- | --- |
| Barber, Lehavy, McNichols & Trueman (2001), Journal of Finance | Buying the most favorably rated stocks and shorting the least, rebalanced daily, earned abnormal gross returns above 4% a year. After trading costs, net returns were not reliably above zero. |
| Barber et al. (2003), Financial Analysts Journal | In 2000–2001 the pattern reversed: the least favored stocks earned 13.44% a year market-adjusted, while the most recommended trailed the market by 7.06%. |
| Jegadeesh, Kim, Krische & Lee (2004), Journal of Finance | The level of consensus added value only for value and positive-momentum stocks. Changes in consensus were the more robust predictor. |

Sources: [Barber et al. 2001](https://ideas.repec.org/a/bla/jfinan/v56y2001i2p531-563.html), [Barber et al. 2003](https://rpc.cfainstitute.org/research/financial-analysts-journal/2003/reassessing-the-returns-to-analysts-stock-recommendations), [Jegadeesh et al. 2004](https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.2004.00657.x). The lesson: a small edge existed for those who traded fast, and it was fragile.

## What happened to stocks after analysts rated them?

Most went up, which is not the same as beating the market. Exent backtested 988,127 ratings from the 1,191 analysts in its ranking over seven years and measured each stock’s price move after the call.

| After the rating | Share of calls where the stock was higher |
| --- | --- |
| 1 month | 54.4% |
| 3 months | 56.8% |
| 6 months | 60.1% |
| 12 months | 64.4% |

The median 12-month price return was +13.6%, and the average drawdown along the way was −22.4%. Statistics as of Nov 16, 2026. These are raw price returns, so a rising market lifts them. For context, the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) returned more than 17% in six of the seven calendar years from 2019 to 2025 in the same data, and fell 18.2% in 2022.

One more caution. Single stocks usually trail the index at the median, because a few big winners drive index returns. Over the year to September 30, 2026, only 40.8% of the 476 largest US stocks beat SPY in that data. Comparing a median stock with the index is not apples to apples. See survivorship bias for a related trap.

## Do the best analysts beat the market?

The best-rated analysts had clearly better records, but that is partly by construction. The star scores used here are based on past accuracy, so the 5★ group looks good on the same history that earned the stars.

| Group | Analysts | Median target hit rate | Median share of calls up after 12 months | Median 12-month return |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 5★ | 143 | 59.0% | 70.2% | +21.0% |
| 4★ | 1,023 | 53.9% | 62.8% | +12.4% |

Source: the same analyst backtest, statistics as of Nov 16, 2026. The honest test of skill is out of sample: does an analyst’s record keep up after you start following them? That is why a useful ranking keeps updating each analyst’s record as new calls play out, rather than scoring them once. See [the most accurate stock analysts](https://www.exent.ai/resources/most-accurate-stock-analysts) and [what a 5‑star analyst is](https://www.exent.ai/learn/analyst-star-rating).

## Exent’s top 50 analysts

Across 988,127 ratings, the average Wall Street analyst’s price target was reached 53.0% of the time: close to a coin flip. The spread between analysts is wide, and 14.4% of the 971 analysts with a measurable record reached 70% or more (Exent data, Nov 16, 2026).

Exent Gems is built on the top 50 of Exent’s ranking. Over the last two years, some of them reached 90% or more of their price targets. Who they are, which stocks they are calling now and how often they have been right is for members.

[Unlock the top 50 analysts](https://www.exent.ai/radar)

## Why don’t analyst recommendations beat the market more often?

- Prices react fast: much of the move happens on the day a rating changes, before most investors can act.
- Ratings are mostly buys, so following them tends to track the market rather than beat it.
- Ratings are often relative to a coverage list, not a promise of absolute gains.
- Capturing what edge exists takes frequent trading, and costs and taxes eat it.
- Incentives push ratings toward optimism, as covered in our guide to analyst bias.

## How can investors use analyst ratings sensibly?

As one input, weighted by track record. Focus on rating changes, on analysts whose past calls held up, and on cases where several strong analysts agree independently. Then check fit with the portfolio you already own.

Even agreement among strong analysts is research, not a recommendation, and not a reliable way to beat the market. Read [whether analyst ratings are biased](https://www.exent.ai/resources/analyst-bias) before you rely on any rating.

## How to weigh analysts by track record with Exent

1. Stocks Radar ranks thousands of Wall Street analysts by past accuracy and keeps updating each record as new calls play out.
2. Analyst profiles show each analyst’s price targets and how their past calls worked out.
3. Gems are Exent’s top picks: stocks where several of the best-rated analysts agree, our hunt for the next big winners. They are research, not a promise to beat the market.
4. Upload your holdings to see which analysts and insiders are active on the stocks you already own.

Exent is our product: [Exent Gems](https://www.exent.ai/radar)

## Frequently asked questions

### Do analyst buy ratings outperform the market?

Not reliably after costs. A 2001 Journal of Finance study found top-rated stocks earned over 4% a year above the market before trading costs, but net returns were not reliably above zero.

### How often do stocks go up after an analyst rating?

In Exent’s 7-year backtest of 988,127 ratings, the stock was higher 12 months later 64.4% of the time. That figure includes the general rise of the market.

### Do 5-star analysts beat the market?

In Exent’s data, 5-star analysts had a median 12-month call return of +21.0% against +12.4% for 4-star analysts. Stars are earned on that same history, so future results can differ.

### Is following analyst upgrades a good strategy?

Research finds changes in ratings carry more information than the rating level, but much of the price move happens quickly. Costs and timing decide whether any edge survives.

### Did analysts get it wrong in the dot-com crash?

Yes. In 2000 and 2001 the stocks analysts liked least beat the market by 13.44% a year, while their favorites trailed it by 7.06%, according to a 2003 Financial Analysts Journal study.

---

Educational content, not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
